Giselle Bedding Rocco Pillow Top Mattress vs Queen Rose 12-Inch Hybrid Mattress

Buy the Queen Rose if you want a hybrid with individually wrapped coils, a bamboo-blend cover, a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Buy the Giselle if you want a simple medium pillow-top and don't mind a shorter 5-year warranty and no sleep trial. The Giselle's Bonnell springs are a basic open-coil design, while the Queen Rose's pocket coils limit motion transfer and are the better long-term build. Owners of budget Bonnell mattresses often report sagging sooner, so the Queen Rose is the safer pick for a main bed.

• Choose the Giselle Bedding if you want a straightforward medium pillow-top queen and a shorter warranty is acceptable to you.
• Choose the Queen Rose if you want pocket coils, a sleep trial and a longer warranty for a main bedroom.