Giselle Bedding Rocco Pillow Top Mattress vs Serta Classic Exclusive Plush PillowTop

The Serta Classic is the better-built mattress: a plush pillow top, wrapped coils, a 10-year limited warranty and CertiPUR-US certification. The Giselle is a medium-firm Bonnell spring mattress with a pillow top and a 5-year warranty, and it suits back and stomach sleepers who want more support. Side sleepers and couples who want a softer, more durable mattress should pick the Serta.

• Choose the Giselle if you want a firmer, more supportive feel and a lower-cost way to furnish a guest or spare room.
• Choose the Serta if you sleep on your side, want a plusher surface and expect the mattress to last through daily use.