SHANY Glamour Girl Makeup Kit vs SHANY All-in-One Makeup Bundle Gift Set

Buy the Glamour Girl kit for the wider color range and a self-contained palette: 48 eyeshadows, 4 blushes, 6 lip creams, a built-in mirror and applicators. Buy the All-in-One Bundle if the person owns almost no tools, since it adds a 10+ piece brush set, eyelash curler, eyeliner, lip gloss and sharpener. The Glamour Girl is the tidier single case and rates 4.7 from 49 ratings, with owners praising pigment and shade variety; the bundle wins on completeness but has more loose pieces to lose.

• Choose the Glamour Girl Makeup Kit if you want the most shades in one compact case with a mirror and applicators built in.
• Choose the SHANY All-in-One Bundle if you need brushes, an eyelash curler and liners along with the makeup, not just the palette.