SHANY Beauty Book Makeup Kit All in one Travel Makeup Set vs SHANY All-in-One Makeup Bundle Gift Set

Both are SHANY all-in-one kits, but they solve different problems. The Beauty Book is a flat, book-style palette packed with 30 eyeshadows, 15 lip creams, brow powders and stencils, so it wins on shade variety and packs flat for travel. The All-in-One Bundle adds a 10+ piece brush set, eyelash curler, eyeliner, sharpener and sponge, so it wins on tools and is the better true starter kit. Owners of both brands' kits praise the variety for the money and note the powders are soft and can be powdery or lightly pigmented, so set expectations for beginner-grade formulas.

• Choose the SHANY Beauty Book if you already own brushes and want the widest spread of eyeshadow and lip shades in one flat, travel-friendly palette.
• Choose the SHANY All-in-One Bundle if you are starting from nothing and want brushes, an eyelash curler and application tools in the same box as the makeup.