Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils vs Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils

Buy the Golden Bear if you need a uniform, reliable box of No. 2 pencils for school, office or test day. Buy the Musgrave factory seconds if you want a large, varied stash of US-made pencils for drawing, workshop or giveaway use and can accept flaws and duplicates. The Golden Bear is a consistent product with a certified non-toxic core and clean cedar barrel; the seconds box is a grab bag where up to half the pencils may match and some will be kids' or promo designs.

  • Choose the Golden Bear if you want 144 matching No. 2 pencils that are safe-certified, consistent and ready for classroom or office use.
  • Choose the Musgrave factory seconds if you want a big mixed batch of US-made pencils cheaply and don't mind flaws, duplicates or novelty designs.

Prices

  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils: $34.95 at Pencils.com (checked today)
  • Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils: $8.00 at Musgrave Pencil Company (checked today)
  • Difference: the Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils is $26.95 cheaper than the Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils today
Golden Bear
Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils)

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils)

$34.95at Pencils.comChecked 59 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Pencils.com
Pros
  • Uniform No. 2 grade suits standardized tests and office use
  • Incense-cedar barrel sharpens cleanly
  • PMA non-toxic certification
  • Made in the USA by Blackwing
Cons
  • Only one design and color per box
  • No variety if you want different pencils
1
144 Factory Seconds Hex or Round

Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils

144 Factory Seconds Hex or Round

4.9(50 ratings)
$8.00at Musgrave Pencil CompanyChecked 55 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Musgrave Pencil Company
Pros
  • Large 144-pencil box of US-made pencils
  • Wide mix of hex and round shapes and designs
  • Good for drawing, workshop or giveaway use
  • Rated 4.9 out of 5 by buyers
Cons
  • Flaws of some kind on every pencil
  • Up to half the box may be near-duplicates
  • No stated lead grade or safety certification
  • Orders can take 1-2 weeks to ship

What separates them

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsMusgrave Factory Seconds Pencils
ConsistencyEvery pencil is the same blue No. 2 with a smooth graphite coreMixed hex and round shapes, up to half the box may be similar designs
ConditionFirst-quality pencilsFactory seconds with flaws of some kind
Lead gradeNo. 2 / HB, uniform across the boxNot specified; varies by pencil
WoodCalifornia-grown incense-cedarUS-made with globally and domestically sourced components
Safety certificationPMA seal, certified non-toxicNo stated certification
VarietyOne design onlyKids' pencils, business and promotional designs mixed in
Best useTests, school, office, everyday writingDrawing, workshop, giveaways, casual use
Shipping speedStandard1-2 week delay possible due to demand

Price history

$34.95$8.00
Nov 6Nov 11
  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils: lowest $34.95 on Nov 9 at Pencils.com; $34.95 on Nov 11.
  • Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils: lowest $8.00 on Nov 6 at Musgrave Pencil Company; $8.00 on Nov 11.

Prices at every store

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

  • Pencils.comNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $34.95Checked 59 min ago
    Visit Pencils.com

Also available at

  • Pencils.comCheck price at Pencils.com
Prices and history →

Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils

  • Musgrave Pencil CompanyNew

    In stock

    $8.00+ $6.70 shippingChecked 55 min ago
    Visit Musgrave Pencil Company

Also available at

  • Musgrave Pencil CompanyCheck price at Musgrave Pencil Company
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecGolden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsMusgrave Factory Seconds Pencils
Wood materialpremium incense cedar—
Barrel shapehexagonal—
Barrel finishglossy, blue-painted—
Lead gradeNo. 2 core—
Country of originMade in the USA—
Wood originCalifornia grown, Incense-cedar—
Package quantity36 #2 pencils per package—
ColorBlue—
Safety certificationPMA seal, certified non-toxic—
ManufacturerBlackwing—
Pack size1 Count (Pack of 36)—
Quantity—1 Gross (144)
Show all 15 specsShow fewer specs
SpecGolden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsMusgrave Factory Seconds Pencils
Pencil shapes—Mixed Hex and Round
Condition—factory seconds
Origin—Made in the USA

What reviewers say

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

Buyers treat these as dependable everyday No. 2 pencils with a smooth core and good cedar wood, and many note the Blackwing connection. Complaints center on the glossy finish and the lack of an eraser.

What people mention
  • Graphite smoothnessPraisedWriters say the No. 2 core lays down dark, smooth lines without scratching.
  • Wood qualityPraisedOwners report the incense-cedar sharpens cleanly and holds a point well.
  • Barrel finishMixedThe glossy blue paint looks sharp but feels slick and scuffs with heavy use.
  • EraserCriticisedBuyers miss having an eraser on the end and keep a separate one handy.

Musgrave Factory Seconds Pencils

  • 4.9 / 550 ratings

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 50 ratings, buyers accept the flaws for the volume and the US origin. The main complaints are the uneven mix and repeated designs.

What people mention
  • FlawsMixedOwners accept that the pencils have cosmetic or other defects given what they pay for the box.
  • AssortmentCriticisedThe mix is not guaranteed, and up to half the box can be one similar design.
  • OriginPraisedBuyers like that the pencils are made in the USA.

Questions and answers

Which is better for standardized tests?
The Golden Bear. Every pencil is a uniform No. 2, which is what test rules require. The seconds box has no stated lead grade and mixes shapes and designs.
Which lasts longer?
Both are wood-cased graphite pencils of similar size, so lifespan depends on sharpening and use. The Golden Bear is first quality, so fewer pencils arrive with defects that shorten their life.
Is the Musgrave box worth stepping up to over the Golden Bear?
Only if you value variety over consistency. The seconds box gives you many designs for casual use, but you give up uniform grade, clean condition and safety certification.
Are the factory seconds safe for kids?
No certification is stated for the seconds, and some pencils are designed for kids while others are business promos. The Golden Bear carries the PMA non-toxic seal, so it is the safer pick for children.
Can I rely on getting a full mix of designs in the seconds box?
No. The maker says it cannot guarantee a full assortment, and up to half the box could be similar designs.
Which is better for an office?
The Golden Bear. Matching blue No. 2 pencils look consistent on desks and work in any sharpener. The seconds box is better suited to a workshop or giveaway bin.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils) vs ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils (12 Pack)
  • 144 Factory Seconds Hex or Round vs ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils (12 Pack)

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best cheap bulk pencils
ValuePraised
Buyers see the box as good value for the number of pencils they get.