Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils vs ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils

Both are hexagonal #2 pencils made from incense-cedar, so writing feel is close. The Golden Bear is made in the USA by Blackwing's manufacturer, comes in a 144-pencil box, and has a painted blue barrel; the ForestChoice is the original FSC-certified pencil, sold in a 12-pack, with a bare natural finish. Buy Golden Bear for a large classroom or office supply with a finished look; buy ForestChoice if certified responsible wood sourcing matters more than pack size.

  • Choose the Golden Bear if you want a big box of US-made pencils with a painted barrel for a classroom, office or shared desk.
  • Choose the ForestChoice if FSC-certified wood and a plain natural finish matter more to you than a large pack.

Prices

  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils: $34.95 at Pencils.com (last seen Nov 9)
  • ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils: $5.00 at Pencils.com (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils is $29.95 cheaper than the Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils at the latest prices (Nov 9)
Golden Bear
Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils)

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils)

$34.95at Pencils.comChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Pencils.com
Pros
  • Made in the USA
  • Large 144-pencil box suits classrooms and offices
  • Painted barrel hides graphite smudges and looks tidy
  • Made by Blackwing, a well-regarded pencil maker
  • PMA non-toxic certification
Cons
  • Glossy paint can feel slick in the hand
  • Only one lead grade and two colors
  • No forest-certification claim on the wood
ForestChoice
ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils (12 Pack)

ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils

ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils (12 Pack)

$5.00at Pencils.comChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Pencils.com
Pros
  • FSC-certified wood, the first pencil to carry it
  • Natural barrel shows the cedar grain
  • Light, plain look many writers prefer
  • Also sold in a 144 box for bulk buyers
Cons
  • Made in Thailand, not the US
  • Small 12-pack means reordering often
  • Bare wood can pick up graphite smudges

What separates them

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils
Lead gradeNo. 2 core (listed as HB in the details table)HB/#2
WoodCalifornia-grown incense-cedarFSC-certified incense-cedar from responsibly managed forests
Country of originMade in the USAMade in Thailand
Pack size144 pencils per box12 pencils per pack, with a 144 box also sold
Barrel finishGlossy blue paint over hexagonal woodBare natural hexagonal wood
CertificationPMA seal, certified non-toxicFSC-C010858
ManufacturerBlackwingForestChoice

Price history

$34.95$5.00
Nov 8Nov 9
  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils: lowest $34.95 on Nov 9 at Pencils.com.
  • ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils: lowest $5.00 on Nov 8 at Pencils.com; $5.00 on Nov 9.

Prices at every store

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

  • Pencils.comNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $34.95Checked Nov 9
    Visit Pencils.com

Also available at

  • Pencils.comCheck price at Pencils.com
Prices and history →

ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils

  • MassageMinder-Appointment Books and Bookkeeping for Massage TherapistsNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $7.00Checked Nov 9
    Visit MassageMinder-Appointment Books and Bookkeeping for Massage Therapists
  • eBayNew

    In stockSold by hmbxxc2026

    $13.55Free shippingChecked Nov 8
    Visit eBay
  • Pencils.comNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $5.00Checked Nov 9
    Visit Pencils.com
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $6.97Checked Nov 8
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • massageminder.netCheck price at massageminder.net
  • Pencils.comCheck price at Pencils.com

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecGolden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils
Barrel shapehexagonalHexagonal
Lead gradeNo. 2 coreHB/#2
Country of originMade in the USAThailand
Package quantity36 #2 pencils per package144
Wood materialpremium incense cedar—
Barrel finishglossy, blue-painted—
Wood originCalifornia grown, Incense-cedar—
ColorBlue—
Safety certificationPMA seal, certified non-toxic—
ManufacturerBlackwing—
Pack size1 Count (Pack of 36)—
Wood type—Incense-cedar
Show all 15 specsShow fewer specs
SpecGolden Bear USA Blue #2 PencilsForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils
Barrel color—Natural
Pencil type—Graphite
Certification—FSC-C010858

What reviewers say

Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils

Buyers treat these as dependable everyday No. 2 pencils with a smooth core and good cedar wood, and many note the Blackwing connection. Complaints center on the glossy finish and the lack of an eraser.

What people mention
  • Graphite smoothnessPraisedWriters say the No. 2 core lays down dark, smooth lines without scratching.
  • Wood qualityPraisedOwners report the incense-cedar sharpens cleanly and holds a point well.
  • Barrel finishMixedThe glossy blue paint looks sharp but feels slick and scuffs with heavy use.
  • EraserCriticisedBuyers miss having an eraser on the end and keep a separate one handy.

Questions and answers

Which is better for school or office bulk buying?
Golden Bear. It ships as a 144-pencil box, so one order covers a class or a supply closet. ForestChoice's standard pack is 12, though a 144 box exists.
Is the ForestChoice actually more eco-friendly?
On paper, yes. Its incense-cedar is FSC-certified (FSC-C010858), which means responsibly managed forests. Golden Bear states California-grown cedar but makes no forest-certification claim.
Do they write the same?
Very close. Both are hexagonal #2/HB pencils in incense-cedar with standard graphite cores. Differences come down to barrel finish and how the wood is sourced, not the line on the page.
Which lasts longer?
Neither stands out on durability. Both use cedar barrels and standard graphite; breakage depends on sharpening and handling more than on the brand.
Is the Golden Bear worth stepping up to over the ForestChoice?
If you want US manufacturing, a Blackwing-made pencil and a big box in one order, yes. If certified wood sourcing is your priority, the ForestChoice is the better fit.
Are either of them non-toxic?
Golden Bear carries the PMA non-toxic seal. ForestChoice's certification covers its wood sourcing, not a separate non-toxic seal.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Golden Bear USA Blue #2 Pencils Bulk (144 Pencils) vs 144 Factory Seconds Hex or Round
  • 144 Factory Seconds Hex or Round vs ForestChoice #2 Graphite Pencils (12 Pack)

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best cheap bulk pencils