Which is better for kitchen spills?

The Ultra Strong 12-pack. Its thicker 2-ply build and larger sheets handle bigger messes better than the Everyday Strong line.

The Ultra Strong 12-pack. It has about 1,320 sheets against 220 in the 2-pack, so it lasts far longer.

Is the Ultra Strong worth stepping up to?

Yes for most homes. You get more sheets, a thicker towel and a higher owner rating, at the cost of more storage space.

Are both Pick-a-Size?

Yes. Both have perforated sheets you can tear in half for small wipes.

Which is easier to store?

The Everyday Strong 2-pack. Two rolls fit in a small cabinet or under a sink; the 12-pack needs more room.

Do they have the same ply?

Yes, both are 2-ply. The difference is the strength grade and pack size.

Great Value Ultra Strong Paper Towels vs Great Value Everyday Strong Paper Towels

Buy the Ultra Strong 12-pack if you want one large supply of thicker 2-ply towels for kitchen and household cleaning. Buy the Everyday Strong 2-pack if you only need a small amount on hand and prefer a smaller pack. Both are Great Value 2-ply towels with Pick-a-Size sheets. Ultra Strong rates higher with owners (4.7 vs 4.5), and the larger pack means fewer restock trips.

Choose the Ultra Strong 12-pack if you want a big supply of thicker towels and fewer trips to restock.
Choose the Everyday Strong 2-pack if you want a small pack for light, routine cleanups.

Prices

Great Value Everyday Strong Paper Towels: $2.96 at Walmart (checked today)