Which is better for growing herbs?

The Mudeela. Its coco coir liner holds soil and drains well, and two 12-inch baskets let you separate herbs. The H Potter is a display bowl, not a growing basket.

Which lasts longer outdoors?

The H Potter. Hammered brass with a copper finish holds up for years. Mudeela's coir liner breaks down with watering and sun and needs replacing.

Is the H Potter worth the extra money?

Only if you want a decorative brass piece you plant directly and keep for years. For everyday flowers and herbs, the $15.99 Mudeela set does the job.

Do I need a liner with the H Potter?

No. You plant straight into the brass bowl, and the drainage hole in the base handles excess water.

How many planters do I get?

The H Potter order is one planter. The Mudeela order is a set of two 12-inch baskets.

Can both be used indoors?

The Mudeela is listed for indoor and outdoor use. The H Potter is listed for outdoor placement on patios, balconies and decks.

H Potter Hammered Brass Hanging Planter vs Mudeela 12-Inch Hanging Planter Baskets

Buy the H Potter if you want one substantial, hand-hammered brass planter that can be planted directly and will last for years. Buy the Mudeela set if you need two 12-inch baskets for herbs or flowers at a low price. The gap is wide: $159.50 at Etsy as of November 5, 2026 versus $15.99 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026.

Today the Mudeela 12-Inch Hanging Planter Baskets costs $143.51 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.