Which ring has the bigger diamond?

Ring A. It lists a 1 ct center stone and offers sizes up to 3.00 ct. Ring B's title says 0.16 Ct .Tw and its description says 0.30 Ct, so it is far smaller either way.

Is lab-grown or natural better for an engagement ring?

They look the same to the eye. Lab-grown (A) buys more size and higher color for the money; natural (B) holds resale value better and suits buyers who want a mined stone.

Which has better clarity?

Ring B lists VS1, above Ring A's SI2, though B's description also says SI1. Ask for the grading report before buying either.

Can I get ring A in yellow gold or platinum?

Yes. Ring A comes in white, yellow, or rose gold from 10K to 18K, plus 925/935 silver and 950 platinum. Ring B is solid 14K gold only.

Which is made in the US?

Ring B states it is made in NYC. Ring A's listing does not state a country of manufacture.

Does ring B come with returns?

Yes. Ring B offers a 30-day return policy and free US insured shipping. Ring A's listing gives no return terms.

Heart Cut Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Ring in Silver or Gold vs Heart-Shape Diamond (0.16 Ct .Tw) Solitaire Ring

Buy the lab-grown solitaire (A) if you want a bigger, whiter stone and a metal choice, since it runs from 0.25 to 3.00 carats in F/SI2 or better and comes in silver, 10K–18K gold, or platinum. Buy the NYC-made ring (B) if you want a small natural diamond and a solid 14K band, but note its own listing gives conflicting carat figures (0.16 Ct .Tw in the title, 0.30 Ct in the description). No prices were provided for either ring, so compare them on the live listings before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent