Which is better for cold climates?

The American Spas tub. Its 5.5 kW titanium heater and Thermo-Shield insulation are built to hold 104 F in cold weather. The DayDream runs on 120V and has no separate high-power heater listed.

Can I install the DayDream without an electrician?

Yes. It ships with a 15-amp GFCI cord and plugs into a standard 120V outlet. You can convert it to 240V later for better heater and jet performance.

Is the American Spas tub worth the extra $1,523?

If you want 40 jets, a stronger heater and an acrylic shell, yes. If you want a simple plug-in tub at the lowest price, the DayDream is the better value.

The American Spas tub has an acrylic shell with a steel-reinforced 7-layer laminate, which generally outlasts rotomolded plastic. The DayDream backs its shell with a 5-year limited warranty.

Which is easier to move and set up?

The DayDream. At 295 lbs dry and 79 inches square, it is far lighter and smaller than the 800-lb, 84-inch American Spas tub, and it needs no 240V wiring.

How many people can each seat?

Both are rated for 6. The American Spas tub has a lounger and 425 gallons of water; the DayDream has a lounger, captain's seats and 240 gallons.

6-Person 40-Jet Acrylic Lounger Hot Tub vs AquaRest DayDream 3500 Hot Tub

Buy the Aquarest DayDream 3500 if you want a plug-and-play spa at the lowest price and don't need deep hydrotherapy. Buy the American Spas 6-person 40-jet lounger if you want stronger jets, a 5.5 kW heater and full 240V performance. The DayDream is $3,599.99 at eBay as of November 8, 2026; the American Spas is $5,123.35 at Overstock as of November 8, 2026, about $1,523 more.

Today the AquaRest DayDream 3500 Hot Tub costs $1,523.36 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.