J.Crew Secret Wash Poplin Shirt vs Tommy Hilfiger Signature Oxford

Buy the J.Crew if you want a softer, lighter poplin shirt that feels broken in on day one and comes in a slim cut. Buy the Tommy Hilfiger if you prefer a regular fit and an oxford weave with more structure. The J.Crew uses finer two-ply yarns and a multistep wash, so it feels smoother and drapes more; the Tommy Oxford is a sturdier, more textured cloth that holds a collar shape better. Both are machine washable cotton with a touch of stretch, and owners of each tend to praise the fabric more than the fit.

• Choose the J.Crew Secret Wash if you want a slim, soft poplin shirt that feels worn-in from the first wear.
• Choose the Tommy Hilfiger Signature Oxford if you want a regular-fit oxford with more structure and a classic button-down look.