Ralph Lauren Classic Fit Oxford Shirt vs Tommy Hilfiger Signature Oxford

The Polo Ralph Lauren Oxford is the safer pick for a traditional, roomy button-down: 100% cotton, a classic fit, and a 4.5 rating across more than a thousand owners back it up. The Tommy Hilfiger Signature Oxford is the better choice if you want a slightly trimmer regular fit and a touch of stretch for all-day movement. Build quality is close on both, but the Polo has the longer track record and the more forgiving cut.

• Choose the Polo Ralph Lauren Oxford if you want a roomy classic-fit button-down in pure cotton with a proven, well-reviewed track record.
• Choose the Tommy Hilfiger Signature Oxford if you prefer a regular fit with a little elastane stretch and organic cotton.