Which is better for a large lawn?

The Agri-Fab 44 in. covers 2 in. more per pass and costs less, so it suits a large lawn on a budget. The John Deere's six brush sections give steadier pickup on uneven ground.

Is the John Deere worth the extra $199?

If you want a welded steel housing and bronze bushings instead of plastic, yes. If you mainly want to clear leaves cheaply, the Agri-Fab does the same 25 cu. ft. job for less.

The John Deere's welded housing and bronze bushings should outlast the Agri-Fab's plastic housing. Agri-Fab buyers report the plastic wheel gears as the first part to fail.

Do both hold the same amount?

Yes. Both list a 25 cu. ft. collection capacity. The Agri-Fab uses a bag and hopper; the John Deere uses a bag with a windscreen.

Can I tow either behind a riding mower?

Yes. Both are tow-behind sweepers. Agri-Fab lists a 3-4 MPH working speed and warns that above 6 MPH you risk stripping the gear teeth.

How hard is assembly?

John Deere lists 30 minutes or less with two tools. Agri-Fab buyers call assembly easy with the Quick Start guide, but some report wrong or short bolts in the hardware kit.

John Deere 42 in. Tow-Behind Lawn Sweeper vs Agri-Fab 44-Inch Tow-Behind Lawn Sweeper

Buy the Agri-Fab 44 in. if you want the lower price and a wider 44 in. sweep for a large lawn; it is $399.99 at Fleet Farm as of November 4, 2026. Buy the John Deere 42 in. if you want a welded steel housing, six brush sections and a self-storing frame, at $599.00 at The Home Depot as of November 4, 2026. The Agri-Fab costs about $199 less, but its plastic wheel gears are the weak point buyers report.

Today the Agri-Fab 44-Inch Tow-Behind Lawn Sweeper costs $199.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent