Jolly Rancher Assorted Hard Candy Bulk Bag vs Charms Party Pack Assorted Candy

Buy the Jolly Rancher bag if you want one consistent hard candy that lasts in the mouth and holds up in a candy dish. Buy the Charms Party Pack if you want variety: lollipops, gummies, bubble gum and caramels in one resealable bag, and you need peanut- and tree-nut-free candy for a group. Jolly Rancher scores higher with owners (4.9 from 140 ratings versus 4.6 from 463), but Charms has far more reviews and a wider mix. Build quality is a wash: both are individually wrapped or wrapped candy in a bag, and Charms adds a resealable pouch.

• Choose the Jolly Rancher if you want a single bold, long-lasting hard candy in classic fruit flavors for bowls, favors or pockets.
• Choose the Charms Party Pack if you want a mixed bag of lollipops, gummies, gum and caramels, and you need peanut- and tree-nut-free candy for a crowd.