StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean vs Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

The Judy Blue Peggy is the safer pick for anyone who wants tummy control and a straight ankle cut that holds its shape. The Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop has the better denim and a more distinctive wide leg, but owner feedback is split: some say it bags out after one wear. Buy Judy Blue for smoothing support and a relaxed straight leg; buy Madewell for structure, raw hems and a wide-leg silhouette.

  • Choose the Judy Blue Peggy if you want a high-rise tummy-control panel, a straight ankle leg, and a petite option with a shorter rise and inseam.
  • Choose the Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop if you want rigid Cone denim with a wide cropped leg, raw hems and Magic Pockets, and you are between 5'4" and 5'8".

Prices

  • Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean: $40.00 at Mattie B's (checked today)
  • Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans: $148.00 at Shopbop (checked today)
  • Difference: the Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean is $108.00 cheaper than the Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans today
Judy Blue
Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean

Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean

Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean

5(2 ratings)
$40.00at Mattie B'sChecked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Mattie B's
Pros
  • Tummy-control panel smooths the front
  • Petite and regular lengths with proportional rises
  • Straight ankle cut suits casual and work wear
  • Stretch fabric moves without losing shape
Cons
  • Straight leg is less fashion-forward than a wide leg
  • Stretch denim feels less premium than rigid Cone denim
  • Limited to one wash family
Madewell
Madewell The Perfect Vintage High-Waist Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

Madewell The Perfect Vintage High-Waist Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

4.8(122 ratings)
$148.00at ShopbopChecked 3 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Shopbop

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Rigid Cone denim with real structure
  • Wide cropped leg with raw hems stands out
  • Magic Pockets hold the front in
  • Strong 4.8 rating across 122 reviews
Cons
  • Some owners say the jeans bag out after one wear
  • Quality complaints at this tier
  • Single cut may not suit shoppers under 5'4"

What separates them

Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle JeanMadewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans
Leg shapeStraight from the knee down, 15" leg openingWide leg, 18" leg opening
Fabric94% cotton, 5% polyester, 1% spandex stretch denim96% Regenagri cotton, 3% EME, 1% elastane; rigid Cone denim
Tummy controlBuilt-in smoothing control panelMagic Pockets give a holds-you-in front
Petite sizingDedicated petite with 10 1/2" rise and 26" inseamOne cut designed for 5'4" to 5'8", 27" inseam
Shape retentionStretch blend that keeps its cutSome owners report bagging out after one wear
HemClean finished ankle hemRaw hem
ClosureButton flyZip fly with button
Owner sentimentPraised for fit and smoothing4.8 of 5 from 122 ratings, but quality complaints

Price history

$148.00$40.00
Nov 18Nov 19
  • Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean: lowest $40.00 on Nov 18 at Mattie B's; $72.90 on Nov 19.
  • Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans: lowest $148.00 on Nov 18 at Shopbop; $148.00 on Nov 19.

Prices at every store

Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean

  • Mattie B'sNew

    In stock

    $40.00+ $9.99 shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Mattie B's
  • The English GardenNew

    In stock

    $59.00+ $6.90 shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit The English Garden
  • The Glossy GoatNew

    Availability unknown

    $62.00Checked 5 h ago
    Visit The Glossy Goat
  • Chic Tique GirlsNew

    Availability unknown

    $65.00Checked 5 h ago
    Visit Chic Tique Girls

Also available at

  • Emma Lou's BoutiqueCheck price at Emma Lou's Boutique
All 12 stores and price history →

Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

  • ShopbopNew

    In stock

    $148.00Free shippingChecked 3 h ago
    Visit Shopbop
  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $148.00Free shippingChecked 3 h ago
    Visit Nordstrom
  • Stitch FixNew

    In stock

    $148.00Checked 3 h ago
    Visit Stitch Fix

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 3 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecJudy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle JeanMadewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans
Inseam26"30" to 32"
Fabric Content94% Cotton, 5% Polyester, 1% Spandex96% Regenagri® certified cotton/3% elastomultie…
FitRelaxed Fitstandard fit but with a proportional rise and s…
RiseHigh RiseHigh-Rise
Front Rise10 1/2"—
Leg Opening15"—
Front Rise (14W)12"—
Inseam (14W)26"—
Leg Opening (14W)17 1/2"—
Inseam SizeInseam Size Regular—
StyleJeans—
MaterialCotton Blend, Polyester, Spandex, Denim—
Show all 22 specsShow fewer specs
SpecJudy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle JeanMadewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans
Leg StyleStraight Leg—
LengthAnkle—
CroppedYes—
ColorPetite 26", Reg 28"—
Size TypeRegular, Petite / Short—
With StretchYes—
With PocketsYes—
Closure TypeButton—
Closure—Zip fly
Designed for height—

What reviewers say

Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

  • 4.8 / 5122 ratings

Buyers rate these highly, praising the flattering high rise, the ankle length that works for petite and average heights, and the fabric weight with its slight stretch. The main complaint is that the denim can bag out after a single wear.

What people mention
  • FitPraisedReviewers say the high rise is flattering and the jeans run true to size.
  • LengthPraisedThe cropped ankle length suits petite and average heights without hemming.
  • FabricPraisedOwners like the substantial Cone denim weight and the slight stretch.
  • Shape retentionCriticisedSome buyers report the jeans bag out and lose their shape after one wear.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a short shopper?
The Judy Blue Peggy. It comes in a dedicated petite with a 10 1/2" rise and 26" inseam. The Madewell crop is built for heights of 5'4" to 5'8".
Which holds its shape longer?
Judy Blue. Its stretch blend is reported to keep its cut, while some Madewell owners say the jeans lost shape and became baggy after one wear.
Is the Madewell worth stepping up to?
If you want rigid Cone denim, raw hems and a wide leg, yes. If you want tummy control and predictable shape, the Judy Blue is the better fit.
Which is more flattering on the stomach?
Both address it. Judy Blue uses a dedicated control panel; Madewell uses Magic Pockets for a holds-you-in front. Judy Blue's panel is the more targeted smoothing feature.
Do the Madewell jeans run true to size?
Buyers call them true to size with slight stretch. The rigid denim starts firm and softens with wear.
Which leg shape is more versatile?
The Judy Blue straight ankle works with flats, sneakers and boots. The Madewell wide crop is a statement cut that pairs best with a fitted top.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Judy Blue High Rise Petite/Reg Dark Wash Retro Wide Leg Jeans vs Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean
  • Fawcett High Rise Straight Leg Jeans Light Blue Wash Petite vs Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean
  • Fawcett High Rise Straight Leg Jeans Light Blue Wash Petite vs Madewell The Perfect Vintage High-Waist Crop Wide-Leg Jeans
  • Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean vs Jean High Rise Wide Straight Leg, Petite in Instructive Wash
  • Judy Blue PEGGY PETITE & Regular High Waisted Tummy Control Ankle Jean vs Levi's Petite Ribcage Straight Ankle Jeans
  • Judy Blue High Rise Petite/Reg Dark Wash Retro Wide Leg Jeans vs Madewell The Perfect Vintage High-Waist Crop Wide-Leg Jeans

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best petite high-waisted jeans
5'4" to 5'8"