Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean vs Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans
The Judy Blue Peggy is the safer pick for anyone who wants tummy control and a straight ankle cut that holds its shape. The Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop has the better denim and a more distinctive wide leg, but owner feedback is split: some say it bags out after one wear. Buy Judy Blue for smoothing support and a relaxed straight leg; buy Madewell for structure, raw hems and a wide-leg silhouette.
- Choose the Judy Blue Peggy if you want a high-rise tummy-control panel, a straight ankle leg, and a petite option with a shorter rise and inseam.
- Choose the Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop if you want rigid Cone denim with a wide cropped leg, raw hems and Magic Pockets, and you are between 5'4" and 5'8".
Prices
- Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean: $40.00 at Mattie B's (checked today)
- Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans: $148.00 at Shopbop (checked today)
- Difference: the Judy Blue Peggy High Waisted Ankle Jean is $108.00 cheaper than the Madewell Perfect Vintage Crop Wide-Leg Jeans today

