Karl Lagerfeld Maybelle Choupette Crossbody vs Quince Italian Leather Patchwork Crossbody

The Quince is the better bag on materials and build: full top-grain Italian leather, cotton twill lining, a back zip pocket and a magnetic flap. The Karl Lagerfeld Maybelle is the more playful choice, with rhinestone Karl and Choupette artwork and a zipper top. Reviewers of the Maybelle like its size, strap and versatility, but some call the faux leather cheap for what it is. Buy the Quince if you want a leather bag that ages well; buy the Maybelle if the character design is the point.

• Choose the Karl Lagerfeld Maybelle if you want the rhinestone Karl and Choupette artwork and a secure zip-top crossbody.
• Choose the Quince if you want real Italian leather, a cotton lining and a cleaner, longer-wearing everyday bag.