Portland Leather Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Quince Italian Leather Patchwork Crossbody

The Quince Italian Leather Patchwork Crossbody is the better-built bag: top-grain Italian leather, a cotton twill lining, and a back zip pocket. The Naomi is roomier in its large sizes and comes in three sizes, but it is unlined faux leather with no real pockets unless you add an organizer. Buy the Quince for a structured, lined crossbody with a secure exterior pocket; buy the Naomi if you want an oversized, lightweight shoulder bag that holds a water bottle.

• Choose the Naomi Shoulder Bag if you want a soft, lightweight over-the-shoulder carry in a large or oversized size that swallows a water bottle and daily errands.
• Choose the Quince Italian Leather Patchwork Crossbody if you want real top-grain leather, a lined interior, and an exterior zip pocket in a compact crossbody.