Kaywood Dresser vs Better Homes & Gardens Lillian Fluted 4-Drawer Dresser

The Kaywood is the wider, lower, six-drawer-style horizontal dresser with English dovetail joinery and center metal glides, and it earns a high rating from a small pool of owners. The Better Homes & Gardens Lillian is a tall four-drawer vertical piece with fluted fronts, a much larger review base, and a lower average score. Pick the Kaywood for a primary bedroom where you want more drawer width and sturdier joinery; pick the Lillian when floor space is tight and you want a narrow footprint. Both are pine-based with veneer surfaces, so neither is heirloom furniture.

• Choose the Kaywood if you have the wall width for a 58.5-inch dresser and want dovetailed drawers with a mid-century rustic look.
• Choose the Lillian if you are furnishing a small room and need a tall, narrow dresser with fluted drawer fronts.