- Which is better for scrambling and technical terrain?
- The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX. Its PU and EVA midsole is torsionally stiff, the Vibram Drumlin/Mont sole grips rock well, and it accepts basic crampons. The La Sportiva is a softer backpacking boot.
- Which fits wide feet?
- The La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX. It uses the Tempo Wide last. The Scarpa's BZH last runs small and narrow, and buyers with wider feet complain about it.
- Is the Scarpa worth the savings?
- At $209.40 versus $258.95, yes if you want a stiffer mountain boot. You give up about 70 g per boot and some cushioning, and you need to size up.
- Which lasts longer?
- The La Sportiva's synthetic upper and EVA midsole should hold up longer for general hiking. Scarpa buyers report the sole wearing relatively quickly and waterproofing leaking after extended use.
- Which is better for long backpacking trips?
- The La Sportiva. Its EVA midsole is more cushioned and the boot is lighter. The Scarpa is firm with limited cushioning on long descents.
- Do both keep feet dry?
- Yes. The La Sportiva uses an ePE Gore-Tex Surround lining and the Scarpa uses Gore-Tex Performance Comfort. Scarpa buyers note the waterproofing can eventually leak with heavy use.