Which is better for a Queen bed?

The Laura Ashley Evie, because the Eddie Bauer Arden Stripe is sold only in Full/Double. The Laura Ashley Queen set includes two standard pillowcases.

Which feels cooler to sleep on?

Both are 200 thread count cotton percale, so they feel similar: crisp and breathable. Neither is a sateen, so neither has a smooth, silky finish.

Which fits a deep mattress?

The Eddie Bauer, which is stated to fit mattresses up to 18 inches deep. The Laura Ashley listing does not state a maximum depth, so check before buying for a thick mattress.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth more than the Laura Ashley?

It is rated slightly higher, 4.6 vs 4.4, and fits deeper mattresses. The Laura Ashley has a recent low of $49.99 on November 6, so compare the current Eddie Bauer price at each store before deciding.

Do both sets include pillowcases?

Yes. The Laura Ashley Queen set includes two standard pillowcases, and the Eddie Bauer is a 4-piece set. Piece counts for other Laura Ashley sizes are not stated.

Both are 200 thread count cotton percale, so wear should be similar. The Eddie Bauer's higher rating suggests fewer complaints, but neither listing gives a warranty or fabric weight.

Laura Ashley Evie Cotton Percale Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Arden Stripe Sheet Set

Both are 200 thread count cotton percale sets, so the choice comes down to fit, pattern and size range. The Laura Ashley Evie comes in five sizes and several prints, and its recent low was $49.99 on November 6, against a high of $63.30 on November 5. The Eddie Bauer Arden Stripe is a gray stripe only, in Full/Double, but it is rated higher (4.6 vs 4.4) and fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. Buy the Laura Ashley for size and color choice; buy the Eddie Bauer for a deeper mattress and a slightly better rating.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.