Lucky Step Retro Thin Sole Sneakers vs Dr. Scholl's Time Off Platform Sneaker

The Dr. Scholl's Time Off is the safer pick for most shoppers. It has a cushioned Ortholite footbed with arch support, a platform sole, and a much larger track record of owner feedback. The Lucky Step is a lighter, flatter retro sneaker with a suede-and-nylon upper and a thin sole; it suits people who want a 90s look and a low, flexible ride. On build, the Dr. Scholl's has more structure and comfort engineering; the Lucky Step is simpler and thinner underfoot.

• Choose the Lucky Step if you want a flat, lightweight 90s-style sneaker with a suede and nylon upper and a thin, flexible sole for casual wear.
• Choose the Dr. Scholl's Time Off if you want a platform sneaker with a cushioned, arch-supporting insole and a long record of owner reviews behind it.