Lucky Step Retro Thin Sole Sneakers vs Skechers Hotshot On the Prowl

Buy the Skechers Hotshot if comfort underfoot matters most: its Air-Cooled Memory Foam insole and 3/4-inch heel give more cushioning than the Lucky Step's flat, thin sole. Buy the Lucky Step if you want the leaner 90s running-shoe look with a nylon and suede upper and padded tongue and collar. Build is close on both, with suede and synthetic uppers and flexible outsoles; the Lucky Step has fewer ratings, so its 4.4 score rests on a small sample, while Skechers is the better-known name for cushioned casual shoes.

• Choose the Lucky Step if you want a slim, retro thin-sole sneaker with a nylon and suede upper and extra foam padding at the ankle.
• Choose the Skechers Hotshot if you want memory foam cushioning and a slightly raised heel in a leopard-print casual shoe.