Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional vs Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman
Buy the Mahoney if you want a full sleeper sectional for under $1,000. Buy the Monterey if you want a deep, down-wrapped modular sofa you can rearrange and keep for years. The gap is steep: $949.99 at Tony's Home Furnishings as of November 4, 2026, versus $6,197.00 at crateandbarrel.com the same day. The Monterey's lowest recent price was $5,597.00 on November 2, 2026, so waiting for a dip can save about $600.
Today the Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional costs $5,247.01 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional
4.5Choose the Mahoney if you need a full-size sleeper, a chaise, and a three-seat sectional for under $1,000.
- Full sleeper version for guests at a budget price
- Chaise plus three seats in a 105 in footprint
- Removable cushions and tufted back
- Available in pebble or chocolate, left or right chaise
What separates them
| Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional | Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $949.99 at Tony's Home Furnishings as of November 4, 2026 | $6,197.00 at crateandbarrel.com as of November 4, 2026 |
| Width | 105 in | 130 in |
| Seating | 3 seats plus a chaise | Two left-arm sofas plus a 45 in ottoman |
| Sleeping | Full memory foam sleeper in sleeper versions | No sleeper; two sofas can be pushed together |
| Cushion fill | Memory foam mattress; standard seat cushions | Polyfoam wrapped in fiber-down blend with down-proof ticking |
| Frame | Corner-blocked wood and metal frame | Kiln-dried hardwood with a Flexolator spring foundation |
| Configuration | Fixed L-shape with left- or right-arm chaise |
Price history
- Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional: lowest $1,099.00 on Oct 29.
- Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman: lowest $5,597.00 on Nov 2 at crateandbarrel.com; $6,197.00 on Nov 4.
Prices at every store
Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional
- Tony's Home FurnishingsNew
In stockReturn policy
$949.99Observed at 9:33 AM - Furniture World NWNew
In stockReturn policy
$1,009.99Observed at 9:33 AM - Capital Discount FurnitureNew
In stockReturn policy
$1,241.10Observed at 9:33 AM
Also available at
- BEL FurnitureCheck price at BEL Furniture
- Furniture OneCheck price at Furniture One
- Price Busters FurnitureCheck price at Price Busters Furniture
Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman
- ModeSensNew
In stock
$6,197.00+ $40.00 shippingObserved at 2:22 AM - crateandbarrel.comNew
Availability unknown
$6,197.00Observed at 9:34 AM
Specs compared
| Spec | Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional | Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman |
|---|---|---|
| Frame material | Wood and Metal | Wood |
| Material | Fabric | Fabric |
| Number Of Pieces | Two Piece | Three Piece |
| Color | Pebble | Blue |
| Pattern | Solid | Solid, Monterey Dd Fbrc Cypress Night |
| Length | 105″ long | 45″ long |
| Depth | 90″ deep | 130″ deep |
| Overall width | 105" W | — |
| Overall depth | 90" D | — |
| Overall height | 37" H | — |
What reviewers say
Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional
Owner feedback on the Mahoney line is generally positive, with a 4.5 average from 105 ratings. Buyers tend to praise comfort and value for the size and call out the sleeper as handy for occasional guests. Complaints center on firmness and on cushions losing shape over time.
- Comfortable for the price
- Sleeper is useful for guests
- Easy to assemble
- Looks good in the room
- Seat cushions soften and flatten with use
- Fabric pills or snags
- Firmer than expected
- Heavy and awkward to move
Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman
Owners rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 142 ratings, with most praise going to comfort and the deep seat. Complaints tend to focus on cushion maintenance and the size of the piece.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a guest room?
- The Mahoney sleeper version, because it includes a full memory foam sofa bed. The Monterey has no sleeper, so guests would sleep on the sofas or ottoman.
- Is the Monterey worth the extra money?
- If you sit on it daily for years, yes. The down-blend cushions, kiln-dried hardwood frame and Flexolator foundation are built to hold up longer than the Mahoney's foam and metal frame.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Monterey. Its hardwood frame and spring foundation are designed to resist sagging, while the Mahoney is an entry-level build with a polyester cover.
- Which fits a smaller room?
- The Mahoney at 105 in wide and 90 in deep. The Monterey runs 130 in wide, so measure the wall before ordering.
- Can I rearrange the Monterey?
- Yes. It ships as two left-arm sofas and an ottoman, so you can split them into separate seating or push them together as one long sofa.
- Does the Monterey price drop?
- It hit $5,597.00 on November 2, 2026, before returning to $6,197.00 on November 4. A price alert can catch the next dip.
More comparisons
- Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional vs Anthropologie Judarn Asymmetric Serpentine Sofa
- Anthropologie Judarn Asymmetric Serpentine Sofa vs Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman
- Mahoney 2 Piece Sectional vs 4-Seat Modular Chaise Sectional
- 4-Seat Modular Chaise Sectional vs Monterey Modular 3-Piece Reversible Sectional Sofa With Ottoman
