Mainstays 6 in Twin Innerspring Mattress vs Ashley Firm 6-Inch Mattress
Buy the Mainstays for a bunk, trundle or dorm bed where you want a firm innerspring feel and a long track record: 9,310 ratings at 4.2 out of 5 is a lot of owner feedback for a cheap twin. Buy the Ashley if you want an all-foam mattress with a 5-year limited warranty and adjustable-base compatibility, but know that its 4.2 rating rests on just 12 reviews. The Mainstays has a gel foam layer over coils and certified materials; the Ashley is a plain high-density foam core with a soft foam top and a stretch-knit cover. Neither is a long-term daily mattress for a heavy adult.
- Choose the Mainstays if you need a firm twin for a bunk, trundle, guest room or dorm and want the reassurance of thousands of owner ratings and OEKO-TEX and CertiPUR-US certifications.
- Choose the Ashley if you want an all-foam firm twin that works on an adjustable base and comes with a 5-year limited warranty.
Prices
- Mainstays 6 in Twin Innerspring Mattress: $88.88 at Walmart (checked today)
- Ashley Firm 6-Inch Mattress: $198.88 at I Save More Furniture & Mattress Store (last seen Nov 10)
- Difference: the Mainstays 6 in Twin Innerspring Mattress is $110.00 cheaper than the Ashley Firm 6-Inch Mattress at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 18)

