Which is better for oily skin?

The Catrice HD Liquid Coverage. It is built for normal to oily skin, dries to a velvety-matte finish, and resists sweat and transfer. The Maybelline is dewy and aimed at dry skin, so it can look shiny on oily skin.

The Catrice, which states up to 24-hour wear and is waterproof, sweatproof and transferproof. Maybelline does not state a wear time for the Fit Me Dewy and Smooth.

Which is better for dry skin?

The Maybelline Fit Me Dewy and Smooth. It is moisturizing and hydrating, fragrance-free, and gives a dewy finish. The Catrice matte formula can emphasize dry patches.

Does either one have sun protection?

Only the Maybelline, which has SPF 18. The Catrice HD Liquid Coverage has no SPF, so you would need a separate sunscreen under it.

Is the Catrice worth it over the Maybelline?

It depends on your skin and coverage needs, not price alone. Pick Catrice for high coverage and long, sweatproof wear; pick Maybelline for hydration, a dewy look and SPF. Compare the current prices at each store before you buy.

Do they come in the same shade range?

No. The Maybelline shade shown is 322 Warm Honey with a neutral undertone; the Catrice shade shown is 036 Hazelnut Beige with a warm undertone. Match to your own skin tone rather than assuming the numbers line up.

Maybelline Fit Me Dewy + Smooth Foundation vs Catrice HD Liquid Coverage Foundation

Buy the Maybelline Fit Me Dewy and Smooth if you have dry or normal skin and want a hydrating, dewy finish with SPF 18 built in. Buy the Catrice HD Liquid Coverage if you have oily or normal skin and need high coverage that stays put through sweat and long days. The Catrice has the higher rating (4.7 from 698 ratings vs 4.3 from 11,444), but the Maybelline has far more ratings behind its score. Check the live prices on both before deciding, since neither is listed here with a price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.