Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara vs Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky Tubes Mascara

Buy the Sky High Washable if you want maximum length and volume with a flexible brush that reaches small lashes. Buy the Sky Tubes if you want easy removal and less smudging, since tubing formulas slide off with warm water. Owners rate the Sky Tubes higher, but the Sky High has far more reviews and a stronger reputation for dramatic lash impact. Both are lightweight and buildable; the trade-off is dramatic hold versus clean, gentle removal.

• Choose the Sky High Washable if you want the most length and volume from a drugstore mascara and don't mind using eye makeup remover at night.
• Choose the Sky Tubes if you want a tubing formula that comes off with warm water and resists smudging through the day.