Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara vs Neutrogena Healthy Volume Mascara

Both are drugstore volumizing mascaras rated 4.3, so the choice comes down to lash style and wear. The Maybelline Sky High is the better pick for dramatic length and a flexible brush that reaches corner lashes; its washable formula also comes in a waterproof version. The Neutrogena Healthy Volume is the gentler, conditioning option, with olive oil and sweet almond oil and a big brush for soft fullness. Owners of both report clumping if you rush the coats, and neither is cruelty-free.

• Choose the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High if you want maximum length and separation, a bendy brush that grabs short lashes, and the option of a waterproof formula.
• Choose the Neutrogena Healthy Volume if you have sensitive eyes or wear contacts and want a conditioning, easy-to-remove mascara with soft volume.