Which is better for oily skin?

The L'Oréal Infaillible. It is oil-free, shine-proof and transfer-proof, and it is positioned for oily skin. The Maybelline suits all skin types but is less oil-controlling.

Which gives more coverage?

The L'Oréal. It is full coverage and targets redness, acne marks and scars. The Maybelline is buildable, so it tops out around medium.

Which lasts longer through sweat and heat?

The L'Oréal. It claims 24-hour wear and is waterproof, heat resistant and transfer-proof. The Maybelline is water resistant and longwear but makes no 24-hour claim.

Is the Maybelline better for sensitive skin?

Likely yes. It is fragrance-free and non-comedogenic and lists sensitive skin as a fit. The L'Oréal is non-comedogenic but not stated as fragrance-free.

Is the L'Oréal worth the extra cost?

Its recent price range was $10.73 to $13.52, which is low for a full-coverage, transfer-proof foundation. If you need full coverage and oil control, it is worth it; if you want a lighter, fragrance-free formula, the Maybelline may suit you better.

Yes. The Maybelline has SPF 16 and the L'Oréal has SPF 25. Neither replaces a dedicated sunscreen for a full day outdoors.

Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte Foundation vs L'Oréal Infaillible 24H Matte Cover Foundation

Buy the L'Oréal Infaillible 24H Matte Cover if you have oily skin, want full coverage, or need a foundation that survives sweat and heat. Buy the Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte if you want lighter, buildable coverage with a softer matte-luminous look and sensitive-skin-friendly, fragrance-free formula. The L'Oréal has ranged from $10.73 to $13.52 in the last few days; the Maybelline price wasn't provided, so compare at checkout.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.