Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer vs Maytag MTW6205RR Top Load Washer

The MTW6205RR is the better buy for most households. It holds 5.2 cu. ft. against 3.5 cu. ft., adds app control, a glass slow-close lid, Deep Fill and a 30-minute Quick Wash, and carries a 10-year limited parts warranty. The MVWP586GW is the simpler, more traditional machine: dials, a 1/2 HP motor and a Dual Action Agitator, with no electronics to learn. Owners rate both around 4.2 to 4.3 out of 5; the smaller Maytag's main complaints are its capacity and lack of a glass lid, the larger one's are its size and the learning curve on its controls.

• Choose the Maytag MVWP586GW if you want a no-frills top loader with simple dials, a strong agitator and a smaller footprint for a tight laundry space.
• Choose the Maytag MTW6205RR if you wash large or bulky loads, want app control and a glass lid, and value the longer parts warranty.