Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer vs Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer

Both are Maytag top-load agitator washers with stainless steel drums and no steam. The MVWP586GW is the simpler machine: dials, 3.5 cu. ft., a 1/2 HP motor and a Dual Action Agitator, and owners rate it well for tough, muddy loads. The larger Maytag adds capacity, a Sanitize with Oxi cycle, auto sensing and a 10-year limited parts warranty on the drive motor and basket, which makes it the better step up for families. Pick the smaller one for a tight laundry space or if you want plain dials; pick the larger one for bulky loads and more cycle choice.

  • Choose the Maytag MVWP586GW if you want a straightforward dial-controlled agitator washer for a small space and mostly everyday or heavily soiled loads.
  • Choose the larger Maytag top-load if you wash for a family, need a sanitize cycle and auto sensing, and want the longer drive-motor and basket warranty.

Prices

  • Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer: $847.00 at St. Louis Appliance Outlet (last seen Nov 9)
  • Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer: $499.00 at The Home Depot (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer is $348.00 cheaper than the Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer at the latest prices (Nov 9)
Maytag
Maytag MVWP586GW Traditional Top Load Washer

Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer

Maytag MVWP586GW Traditional Top Load Washer

4.3(612 ratings)
$847.00at St. Louis Appliance OutletChecked 10 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit St. Louis Appliance Outlet
Pros
  • Simple dial controls that are easy to repair and hard to confuse
  • Dual Action Agitator and 1/2 HP motor handle heavy, muddy loads
  • Deep Water Wash and presoak options suit stained work clothes
  • Compact 27 in width fits tight laundry closets
Cons
  • Smaller 3.5 cu. ft. drum struggles with king comforters
  • No sanitize cycle and no auto sensing
  • No steam and not Energy Star certified
  • Fewer cycles than the larger model
Maytag
Top-Load 5.2 cu. ft. Capacity Agitator Washer

Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer

Top-Load 5.2 cu. ft. Capacity Agitator Washer

$499.00at The Home DepotChecked 11 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit The Home Depot
Pros
  • Bigger 4.2 cu. ft. drum takes bulky bedding and family loads
  • Sanitize with Oxi cycle for germs and tough stains
  • Auto sensing sets water level; Deep Fill tops it up when needed
  • 10-year limited parts warranty on drive motor and wash basket
Cons
  • No window in the lid
  • No steam and not Energy Star certified
  • Digital and mechanical mix is busier than plain dials
  • Heavier machine at 139 lb, harder to move

What separates them

Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load WasherMaytag Top-Load Agitator Washer
Capacity3.5 cu. ft.4.2 cu. ft. (5.2 cu. ft. listed on the product name)
ControlsMechanical dials with 4 water levelsDigital and mechanical controls with cycle status light, 4 water levels
Wash cycles7 cycles including Bulky, Delicates, Mixed, Rinse & Spin, Drain & Spin10 cycles including Sanitize with Oxi
Water and sensingManual water level selector with Deep Water Wash; out-of-balance sensingAuto sensing with Deep Fill and two extra rinse options
Motor and drum warrantyStandard Maytag limited parts warranty10-year limited parts warranty on drive motor and stainless steel basket
Footprint and height27 in wide, 26 in deep, 52 in tall with lid openAbout 27.5 in wide, 27 in deep, 42 in tall
Energy use720 W draw, not Energy Star certified281 kWh per year, not Energy Star certified
BuildStainless steel drum, painted lid, 1/2 HP motorStainless steel drum, no window, 139 lb net weight

Price history

  • Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer: lowest $891.96 on Nov 9 at Nordam Appliance.
  • Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer: lowest $499.00 on Nov 9 at The Home Depot.

Prices at every store

Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer

  • Nordam ApplianceNew

    In stock

    $891.96Free shippingChecked 11 h ago
    Visit Nordam Appliance
  • Mike’s Appliance CenterNew

    In stock

    $899.00+ $79.99 shippingChecked 11 h ago
    Visit Mike’s Appliance Center
  • Appliance SolutionsNew

    In stock

    $899.99+ $79.00 shippingChecked 11 h ago
    Visit Appliance Solutions
  • St. Louis Appliance OutletNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $847.00Checked 10 h ago
    Visit St. Louis Appliance Outlet
All 22 stores and price history →

Maytag Top-Load Agitator Washer

  • The Home DepotNew

    In stock

    $499.00Checked 11 h ago
    Visit The Home Depot
  • R. Brooks & SonNew

    In stock

    $598.00Checked 11 h ago
    Visit R. Brooks & Son
  • earlbfeiden.comNew

    In stock

    $598.50Checked 11 h ago
    Visit earlbfeiden.com
  • Shore Appliance ConnectionNew

    In stock

    $598.00+ $99.00 shippingChecked 11 h ago
    Visit Shore Appliance Connection
All 14 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecMaytag MVWP586GW Top Load WasherMaytag Top-Load Agitator Washer
Washer Capacity3.5 cu. ft.4.2 cu. ft.
Depth26 in68.6 cm
Height52 in (with Lid Open)106.7 cm
Width27 in69.9 cm
Energy Star CertifiedNoNo
Wash Action TypeAgitatorAgitator
Washing MechanismAgitatorAgitator
Steam FunctionNoNo
Washing FeaturesWater Level Selector with Deep Water WashSanitize w/ Oxi, Auto Sensing, Deep Fill
Heavy DutyYesYes
Load BalanceYes (out of balance sensing)Auto Sensing
High EfficiencyYesYes
Show all 40 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMaytag MVWP586GW Top Load WasherMaytag Top-Load Agitator Washer
Energy Consumption720 W281 kWh (per year)
TypeWasherWasher
SubtypeTop Load WasherTop Load Washer
Control PanelDialsDigital & Mechanical
Door StylePainted (Lid/Door)No window
Drum MaterialStainless SteelStainless Steel
Interior LightNoNo
Design Highlights4 Water Level Selector with Deep Water WashCycle Status Light
Control TypeDialsMechanical

What reviewers say

Maytag MVWP586GW Top Load Washer

  • 4.3 / 5612 ratings

Owners rate it well for cleaning power and quick cycles, and many bought it to replace a failed front loader or impeller machine. Complaints center on water and energy use and on the agitator being hard on delicate fabrics.

What people mention
  • Cleaning powerPraisedOwners say the agitator lifts dirt from work clothes and kids' laundry that impeller machines left behind.
  • Cycle speedPraisedReviewers like that normal and heavy loads finish quickly compared with longer HE cycles.
  • Water useCriticisedSeveral owners note it fills deeper and uses more water than high-efficiency washers.
  • Delicates careCriticisedSome say the agitator is rough on sweaters and thin fabrics, so they wash those by hand.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a family of four?
The larger Maytag. Its 4.2 cu. ft. drum and Sanitize with Oxi cycle handle more laundry per load and more soil types than the 3.5 cu. ft. MVWP586GW.
Which one lasts longer?
Both use stainless steel drums and agitators. The larger model backs its drive motor and wash basket with a 10-year limited parts warranty, which is the stronger long-term coverage.
Is the bigger one worth stepping up to?
Yes if you wash bedding, towels or kids' clothes often. The extra capacity, auto sensing and sanitize cycle do more than the smaller model's dials and Deep Water Wash.
Does either washer have steam?
No. Neither has a steam function, and neither is Energy Star certified. Both are high-efficiency agitator top-loaders.
Which fits a small laundry closet better?
The MVWP586GW. It is 27 in wide and 26 in deep, while the larger model is about 27.5 in wide and 27 in deep and weighs 139 lb.
Can I wash a king comforter in either?
The larger model is the safer bet at 4.2 cu. ft. The 3.5 cu. ft. MVWP586GW is tight for a king comforter and better suited to queen size or smaller.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Maytag MVWP586GW Traditional Top Load Washer vs Maytag High Efficiency Agitator Extra Large Top Load Washer MTW6205RR
  • Top-Load 5.2 cu. ft. Capacity Agitator Washer vs Top-Load Washer with 2-in-1 Removable Agitator
  • Maytag High Efficiency Agitator Extra Large Top Load Washer MTW6205RR vs Top-Load 5.2 cu. ft. Capacity Agitator Washer
  • Maytag MVWP586GW Traditional Top Load Washer vs Top-Load Washer with 2-in-1 Removable Agitator

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Maytag top load washing machines with agitator
color
White
—
PlacementFreestanding—
Product TypeWashing Machine—
Load TypeTop Load—
Loading MethodTop Load—
Wash CyclesRinse & Spin, Bulky, Delicates, Drain & Spin, M…—
Cycle OptionsExtra Rinse, Presoak, Presoak & Extra Rinse—
Total Capacity—4.2 cu. ft.
Stackable—No
Installation Type—Freestanding
Capacity—147.16 l, 5.2 cu. ft.
Capacity IEC Canada—169.80 l, 6 cu. ft.
Net Weight—63.05 kg, 139 lbs
Gross Weight—69.85 kg, 154 lbs
Number of Wash Cycles—10
Number of Water Levels—4
Number of Temperatures—5
Motor Drive Type—Direct Drive
Connectivity—Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant