Callaway Insulated Softshell Golf Vest vs Callaway Men's Quilted Puffer Golf Vest

Buy the softshell vest if you play in cold, wet or windy weather and want one warm layer. Buy the quilted puffer vest if you want a light, packable layer for mild mornings and sunny rounds. The softshell is the heavier, more technical piece: a wind-tight, water-repellent shell, heat-reflective lining and over 400g of insulation, with four zipper pockets and a drawcord hem. The puffer is simpler: quilted front-panel insulation, a plain weave shell, sun-protective fabric and a straight hem. Owners rate the puffer well at 4.6 from 251 ratings and call it good value; the softshell has no owner rating here, so judge it on its specs.

• Choose the softshell vest if you want real cold-weather warmth, wind and light-rain protection, and secure zipper pockets.
• Choose the quilted puffer vest if you want a light layer for cool mornings that packs down and won't get in the way of your swing.