Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set vs Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set
Buy the Montauk if you want solid pine construction and a bigger five-piece bundle with a tall chest. Buy the Madison if storage built into the bed itself matters more than wood type. The Montauk rates higher with far more owners (4.8 from 672 versus 4.1 from 51), and owners praise its hand-distressed solid wood. The Madison is a smaller four-piece set with a bookcase headboard, footboard drawers and side-rail drawers, but its panels are engineered wood and the set skips the chest.
- Choose the Montauk if you want all-solid-pine furniture, a five-piece set with a separate chest, and the stronger owner track record.
- Choose the Madison if you want drawers and shelves built into the bed frame and a bookcase headboard, and you can live without a chest.
Prices
- Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set: $1,925.00 at Amazon (last seen Nov 15)
- Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set: $759.20 at elettrodomestici.shop (last seen Nov 10)
- Difference: the Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set is $1,165.80 cheaper than the Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 15)

