StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set vs Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set

Buy the Montauk if you want solid pine construction and a bigger five-piece bundle with a tall chest. Buy the Madison if storage built into the bed itself matters more than wood type. The Montauk rates higher with far more owners (4.8 from 672 versus 4.1 from 51), and owners praise its hand-distressed solid wood. The Madison is a smaller four-piece set with a bookcase headboard, footboard drawers and side-rail drawers, but its panels are engineered wood and the set skips the chest.

  • Choose the Montauk if you want all-solid-pine furniture, a five-piece set with a separate chest, and the stronger owner track record.
  • Choose the Madison if you want drawers and shelves built into the bed frame and a bookcase headboard, and you can live without a chest.

Prices

  • Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set: $1,925.00 at Amazon (last seen Nov 15)
  • Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set: $759.20 at elettrodomestici.shop (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set is $1,165.80 cheaper than the Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 15)
M
Montauk Bedroom Set (5-Piece)

Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set

Montauk Bedroom Set (5-Piece)

4.8(672 ratings)
$1,925.00at AmazonChecked Nov 15
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Solid pine throughout, with hand-distressed grain that varies piece to piece
  • Five pieces including a chest, so storage spreads across the room
  • Metal drawer glides and replaceable pulls
  • High owner rating across a large number of reviews
  • Wood sourced from renewable forests
Cons
  • No storage in the bed frame
  • Box spring required on Full, Queen and King
  • Full assembly needed
  • Back panels are semi-finished or unfinished
Picket House Furnishings
Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set

Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set

Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set

4.1(51 ratings)
$759.20at elettrodomestici.shopChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit elettrodomestici.shop
Pros
  • Storage built into the headboard, footboard and side rails
  • Bookcase headboard with two shelves
  • No box spring required
  • Dust proofing on bottom drawers
  • Mirror included
Cons
  • No chest in the set; only one nightstand
  • Lower owner rating from a much smaller review pool
  • Anti-tipping hardware only on the dresser
  • Engineered wood panels rather than solid pine

What separates them

Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom SetPicket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set
Set contentsBed, 6-drawer dresser, 5-drawer chest, two 2-drawer nightstandsBed, dresser, mirror, one nightstand
Primary material100% solid pine from renewable forests, hand-sanded and distressedWood with a gray oak finish; panels are not described as solid
Bed storageNone; the bed is a standard frameTwo shelves and two drawers in the headboard, four drawers in the footboard, one drawer per side rail
Box springRequired on Full, Queen and King; not on TwinNot required
Drawer hardwareMetal glides with replaceable rustic metal pullsSilver knobs; bottom drawers have dust proofing
Safety featuresChest has a drawer interlocking mechanism for tip-over safetyAnti-tipping hardware on the dresser only
Owner feedback4.8 out of 5 from 672 ratings4.1 out of 5 from 51 ratings
AssemblyFull assembly requiredAssembly required

Price history

$1,925.00$759.20
Nov 10Nov 15
  • Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set: lowest $1,925.00 on Nov 15 at Amazon.
  • Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set: lowest $759.20 on Nov 10 at elettrodomestici.shop; $1,799.74 on Nov 14.

Prices at every store

Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set

  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $1,925.00Free shippingChecked Nov 15
    Visit Amazon
  • Grain Wood FurnitureNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $1,939.00Checked 40 min ago
    Visit Grain Wood Furniture

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set

  • elettrodomestici.shopNew

    In stock

    $759.20Checked Nov 10
    Visit elettrodomestici.shop
  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $1,799.74Checked Nov 14
    Visit Walmart
  • The Home DepotNew

    In stock

    $2,246.27Free shippingChecked Nov 14
    Visit The Home Depot
  • Miller's Dutch Haus FurnitureNew

    In stock

    $9,921.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit Miller's Dutch Haus Furniture

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecMontauk 5-Piece Bedroom SetPicket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set
Furniture In Set—Nightstand, Bed, Dresser
Assembled height—26 in
Color—Gray
Finish—Oak
Shape—Rectangular
Assembly required—Y
Number of drawers—Two Drawers
Tray—Pull Out Tray
Hardware—Silver Knobs
Dust proofing—Dust Proofing on Bottom Drawer
Bed size—King
Items included—Bed
Show all 33 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMontauk 5-Piece Bedroom SetPicket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set
Piece count—1
Material—Wood
Bed type—Standard Beds
Brand—Picket House Furnishings
Decor style—Contemporary
Box spring required—N
Headboard style—Bookcase
Assembly req—Y
Rec. room—Bedroom
Rec location—

What reviewers say

Montauk 5-Piece Bedroom Set

  • 4.8 / 5672 ratings

Rated 4.8 out of 5 from 672 ratings, owners are largely pleased with the Montauk set. They like the solid wood feel and the storage the dresser and chest provide. Complaints center on the box-spring requirement and the unfinished backs.

What people mention
  • BuildPraisedOwners describe the pieces as solid and sturdy for the money.
  • StoragePraisedThe six-drawer dresser and five-drawer chest are called roomy enough for a full bedroom.
  • Box springCriticisedBuyers of Full, Queen and King sizes note the extra box-spring purchase and setup.
  • FinishMixedThe natural grain is liked, but the unfinished backs and back panel draw complaints.

Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set

  • 4.1 / 551 ratings

Owners give the set solid marks for storage and looks, with a 4.1 average from 51 ratings. Many praise the bed storage and the coordinated gray finish. Complaints center on assembly effort and occasional quality-control issues.

What people mention
  • StoragePraisedOwners repeatedly highlight the storage on all sides of the bed and in the dresser and nightstand.
  • AssemblyCriticisedMany say putting the set together is a long, involved job.
  • FinishMixedThe gray oak look draws compliments, but some report inconsistencies or damage on arrival.
  • DrawersMixed

Questions and answers

Which set is better for a small bedroom?
The Madison. Its bed holds clothes and linens in the headboard, footboard and side rails, so you can skip a chest. The Montauk needs floor space for a separate chest and two nightstands.
Which one lasts longer?
The Montauk is the safer bet for long-term wear. It is solid pine with metal drawer glides, and owners report it holding up for years. The Madison uses wood panels with a gray finish and has a thinner review record.
Do I need a box spring?
With the Montauk, yes on Full, Queen and King sizes; the Twin does not need one. The Madison does not require a box spring at all.
Is the Madison worth stepping up to over the Montauk?
Only if built-in bed storage is your priority. The Montauk gives you more pieces, solid wood and stronger owner ratings. The Madison gives you drawers and shelves in the bed itself.
Which has more drawer space?
The Montauk, counting case pieces: six dresser drawers, five chest drawers and four nightstand drawers. The Madison spreads its storage across the bed frame plus the dresser and nightstand.
Can I use an adjustable base with either bed?
The Montauk bed is listed as compatible with most adjustable bases of equal or lesser size than the mattress space. The Madison is a storage bed with drawers in the frame, so an adjustable base does not fit it.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • 5 Pieces Bedroom Furniture Set, Includes Queen Size Bed Frame with Headboard, Nightstand Sets of 2,6-Drawers Dressers and 4-Drawers Dressers with Cutout Handle vs Montauk Bedroom Set (5-Piece)
  • 5 Pieces Bedroom Furniture Set, Includes Queen Size Bed Frame with Headboard, Nightstand Sets of 2,6-Drawers Dressers and 4-Drawers Dressers with Cutout Handle vs Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set
  • Montauk Bedroom Set (5-Piece) vs Roundhill Renova 5-Piece French King Set
  • Shaker Bedroom Set (5-Piece) vs Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set
  • Mid Century Bedroom Set (5-Piece) vs Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set
  • Clelane 6-Piece Shiplap Queen Suite vs Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set
  • Roundhill Renova 5-Piece French King Set vs Picket House Furnishings Madison Storage Bedroom Set

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best bedroom furniture sets
  • Best king bedroom sets
Indoor
Has mirror—Y
Age group—Adult
Model—EG170KB4PC
Product line—Madison
Mirror type—Dresser Mirror
Color category—Gray
Total count—1
Upholstered—N
Configuration—4 Piece Set
Size—King
Number of Products (pcs)—3.0
Drawers are roomy, yet some owners find the glides stiff or the fronts flimsy.