Clelane 6-Piece Shiplap Queen Suite vs Picket House Madison Storage Bedroom Set

The Clelane suite is the better pick for a traditional bedroom that needs a full matching set with a tall chest and a wide dresser. Its solid wood and veneer build, dovetail drawers and full-extension ball-bearing glides are a step above the Madison's more basic construction. The Madison wins on storage in the bed itself and on a lower, easier-to-reach profile, and its 4.1 rating from 51 owners is decent but not glowing. Buy the Clelane for build quality and set completeness; buy the Madison if you want drawers built into the bed and a simpler gray oak look.

• Choose the Clelane if you want a complete six-piece farmhouse set with a tall chest, a wide dresser and sturdier drawer hardware.
• Choose the Madison if you want storage built into the bed and a compact gray oak set that takes up less wall space.