Which is better for layering?

The Naadam is described as a light, layerable weight and is cropped, so it sits well over a higher-waisted bottom. The Banana Republic is also lightweight but longer at 23.5 inches, which suits tucking or wearing over a tee.

Is the Banana Republic worth the savings?

At $49.95 versus $78.00 as of November 7, 2026, it saves about $28. You trade a new-goods listing and cable knit for a resale piece in one size and color set.

Both are 100% cashmere and need gentle care, so lifespan depends on washing and storage more than brand. The Banana Republic allows dry cleaning, which is the lower-risk option for a knit you want to keep for years.

Does the Naadam run short?

Yes. It is sold as a short, cropped classic length, so expect it to end above the hip. The Banana Republic at 23.5 inches is the longer of the two.

Can I get the Banana Republic in my size?

The listing shown is a single resale item in size Large with a 20-inch chest. Check the listing's measurements against a sweater you own before buying.

Which is the better deal right now?

The Banana Republic is cheaper at $49.95, but it is a resale listing. The Naadam at $78.00 is new and has ranged from $78.00 to $138.00 since November 1, 2026, so $78.00 is its low end.

Naadam Cashmere Short Sleeve Crewneck vs Banana Republic Cashmere Short-Sleeve Sweater

Both are 100% cashmere short-sleeve crewnecks, so the choice comes down to fit and price. The Banana Republic is the cheaper buy at $49.95 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $78.00 for the Naadam at Amazon. Pick the Naadam for a cropped, cable-knit look with a known new-goods listing; pick the Banana Republic for a longer, plainer sweater at a lower price, accepting that the listed item is a resale piece in size Large.

Today the Banana Republic Cashmere Short-Sleeve Sweater costs $28.05 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.