Pura Cashmere Short Sleeve Cashmere Crew vs Banana Republic Cashmere Short-Sleeve Sweater

Buy the Pura Cashmere crew if you want a dressier, lighter layer with a silk blend and a pointelle back detail. Buy the Banana Republic sweater if you want plain 100% cashmere in a simple crew and a straight hem. Pura's 160 g ribbed knit and seamless sides give it a cleaner line under a blazer, and its 40 ratings are all 5s. Banana Republic's 4.7 from 36 ratings is close, and its Good Cashmere Standard sourcing is a plus, but the fabric is plainer and the fit is boxier.

• Choose the Pura Cashmere crew if you want a soft silk-blend layer with a back detail that works under a jacket or on its own.
• Choose the Banana Republic sweater if you want straightforward 100% cashmere in a basic crew with a straight hem.