Nathan James Gracie Counter Stool vs Lumisource Cosmo Mid-Century Bar Stool

Buy the Nathan James Gracie if you want a fabric-upholstered stool with a real back, a 300 lb rating and a flax cover that hides wear. Buy the Lumisource Cosmo if you want the mid-century look, a padded faux-leather seat and a lower, lighter piece for a kitchen island. The Gracie is the sturdier, more supportive chair; the Cosmo is the more decorative one, and its faux leather wipes clean where the flax will not.

• Choose the Nathan James Gracie if you want a backed counter stool rated to 300 lb with a washable-feel flax cover and rubberwood frame.
• Choose the Lumisource Cosmo if you want a mid-century walnut-and-cream stool with a padded seat that wipes clean and a footrest.