Which is better for a busy family kitchen?

The simplehuman, if budget allows. Its 45 liters is smaller than the Ninestars' 13.2 gallons, but the soft-close lid, adaptive sensor and liner pocket hold up better to daily use.

The simplehuman is the safer bet. It has a 10-year parts and labor warranty and a steel body; the Ninestars lists no warranty.

Is the simplehuman worth the extra money?

Yes if you want a can that lasts a decade and looks good in a premium kitchen. At $169.99 versus $46.91, the Ninestars is the better value for a garage, office or rental.

Which holds more trash?

The Ninestars, at 13.2 gallons (50L) versus 45 liters (about 11.9 gallons).

Do both run on batteries?

The simplehuman uses a USB-rechargeable battery included in the box. The Ninestars power source is not stated, so check the listing before buying.

Which fits in a tighter space?

The Ninestars is narrower at 11.22 inches wide, but deeper at 15.24 inches. The simplehuman is wider at about 15.4 inches but shallower at 12.8 inches.

Ninestars 13 Gallon Automatic Trash Can vs simplehuman 45L Semi-Round Sensor Trash Can

The Ninestars is the budget pick at $46.91 at Amazon as of November 6, 2026, and it does the basic job: a sensor lid, 13.2 gallons, and a bag ring. The simplehuman costs far more at $169.99 at Best Buy as of November 6, 2026, but it brings a 10-year warranty, a rechargeable battery, soft-close lid and a liner pocket. Buy the Ninestars for a low-cost kitchen or office can; buy the simplehuman if you want a can that lasts and looks good in a premium kitchen.

Today the Ninestars 13 Gallon Automatic Trash Can costs $123.08 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.