Ophanie Large Grey Shag Area Rug 9x12 vs Garvee 10x13 Fuzzy Shag Area Rug

Buy the Ophanie if you want a 9x12 shag with a machine-washable care instruction, a non-slip dot backing and a long track record of 30,000-plus ratings. Buy the Garvee if you need a larger 10x13 footprint and a fuzzier, fur-like pile for a big living room. The Ophanie is the safer pick for kids, pets and high-traffic rooms; the Garvee's higher rating rests on far fewer reviews.

• Choose the Ophanie if you want a 9x12 shag with a non-slip backing, machine-wash care and a large base of owner ratings.
• Choose the Garvee if you need a bigger 10x13 rug and prefer a longer, fur-like shag pile.