StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Pendleton Women's Board Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Buy the Pendleton if you want a warm, hard-wearing wool shirt that shrugs off cold and lasts for years. Buy the Lucky Brand if you want a soft, easy cotton plaid you can throw in the dryer and wear indoors. The Pendleton is the better-built shirt, with dense 10.3 oz virgin wool woven in Pendleton's US mills and a women's cut of a proven men's design. The Lucky Brand is lighter and simpler, and owners call the fabric thick for cotton with good colors.

  • Choose the Pendleton Women's Board Shirt if you want real warmth, a relaxed wool overshirt that holds up for seasons, and a classic plaid look.
  • Choose the Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up if you want a soft washed cotton shirt that is easy to wash and dry and works indoors.

Prices

  • Pendleton Women's Board Shirt: $210.00 at Cowboy Shop (checked today)
  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt: $79.50 at Nordstrom (checked today)
  • Difference: the Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt is $130.50 cheaper than the Pendleton Women's Board Shirt today
Pendleton
Pendleton Women's Board Shirt

Pendleton Women's Board Shirt

$210.00at Cowboy ShopChecked 4 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Cowboy Shop
Pros
  • Warm 10.3 oz virgin wool
  • Two flap chest pockets
  • US-woven fabric
  • Proven Board Shirt design
  • Machine washable wool
Cons
  • Must line dry
  • Can feel scratchy against skin
  • Too warm for summer
  • Wool needs gentle care
Lucky Brand
Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

5(1 rating)
$79.50at NordstromChecked 46 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Soft washed cotton
  • Tumble dry safe
  • Easy everyday layering
  • Button cuffs and spread collar
  • Owners praise the colors and fabric weight
Cons
  • Only one pocket
  • Less warm than wool
  • Cotton wears out sooner
  • Not built for cold weather

What separates them

Pendleton Women's Board ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
Material100% pure virgin wool, 10.3 oz100% washed cotton
WarmthBuilt for fall and winter layeringLight layer for mild weather
CareMachine wash cold, gentle; line dryTumble dry
Fabric originWoven in Pendleton's American millsImported
FitRelaxed women's cut of the men's Board ShirtStandard button-up with spread collar
PocketsTwo flap chest pocketsOne chest pocket
HemShirttail hem, square bottomStraight hem
DurabilityDense wool that resists wearSofter cotton that wears faster

Price history

$210.00$53.26
Nov 10Nov 18
  • Pendleton Women's Board Shirt: lowest $141.75 on Nov 10 at McKenna's Pendleton; $210.00 on Nov 17.
  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt: lowest $53.26 on Nov 17 at Nordstrom; $79.50 on Nov 18.

Prices at every store

Pendleton Women's Board Shirt

  • PendletonNew

    In stock

    $210.00Free shippingChecked 4 h ago
    Visit Pendleton
  • Cowboy ShopNew

    In stock

    $210.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Cowboy Shop
  • McKenna's PendletonNew

    In stock

    $210.00+ $9.95 shippingChecked 4 h ago
    Visit McKenna's Pendleton
  • Frontier RelicsNew

    Availability unknown

    $210.00Checked 4 h ago
    Visit Frontier Relics
All 4 stores and price history →

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $79.50Free shippingChecked 46 min ago
    Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecPendleton Women's Board ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
Material100% pure virgin woolCotton
PatternSolidCheckered
ColorRed, BlueMulticolor
Fabric weight10.3 oz.—
Fabric originFabric woven in our American mills—
PocketsTwo flap chest pockets—
HemSquare bottom—
CareMachine wash with like colors, cold, gentle cyc…—
DryingLine dry—
Tall fitTall fits men 6' and up—
Length (size M)30—
Chest (size M)45—
Show all 23 specsShow fewer specs
SpecPendleton Women's Board ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
DepartmentWomen's—
Size TypeRegular—
Care InstructionsMachine Wash—
Pocket StyleFlap—
SeasonFall, Winter—
Washing Instructions—Tumble Dry
Cotton (%)—100
Closure—Buttons
Neckline—Shirt Collar
Sleeves—

What reviewers say

Pendleton Women's Board Shirt

Owners of the Board Shirt line praise the dense wool, the build and the fact that it survives machine washing. The women's cut draws the same loyalty as the men's, with fit and initial scratchiness the main points of debate.

What people mention
  • Wool feelMixedOwners find the wool dense and warm but scratchy next to skin until it softens with wear.
  • WarmthPraisedReviewers treat it as a genuine cold-weather shirt that layers well over a tee.
  • FitMixedThe relaxed women's cut suits some buyers, while others find it roomy or boxy.
  • DurabilityPraisedLong-time owners report the shirt holding up through seasons of regular wear.

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Buyers describe it as a great shirt overall, praising the colors and the fabric, which several note is pretty thick in a good way.

What people mention
  • Fabric weightPraisedBuyers say the cotton is pretty thick and like the substantial feel.
  • ColorsPraisedReviewers call the plaid colors great.
  • Overall qualityPraisedBuyers sum it up as a great shirt overall.

Questions and answers

Which is warmer for winter?
The Pendleton. Its 10.3 oz virgin wool traps heat and is made for fall and winter. The Lucky Brand is a light cotton shirt for milder days or indoor wear.
Which is easier to care for?
The Lucky Brand. It goes in the dryer. The Pendleton needs a cold gentle wash and line drying to keep its shape.
Which lasts longer?
The Pendleton. Dense wool resists wear and pilling far better than washed cotton, which thins and fades with repeated washing.
Is the Pendleton worth stepping up to?
Yes if you want a cold-weather overshirt you keep for years. Skip it if you want a soft shirt for indoor wear, where the Lucky Brand is the easier pick.
Does the Pendleton run large?
It is a relaxed fit cut from the men's Board Shirt, so it runs roomier than a standard women's shirt. Size down if you want it closer to the body.
Can I wear the Lucky Brand as an overshirt?
Yes, but it is thinner than the Pendleton. It works over a tee in mild weather, not as a jacket substitute in cold.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid vs Lucky Brand Cropped Plaid Corduroy Button-Up Shirt
  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid
  • True Religion Long-Sleeve Plaid Button-Up Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid
  • Pendleton Women's Board Shirt vs Lucky Brand Cropped Plaid Corduroy Button-Up Shirt
  • True Religion Long-Sleeve Plaid Button-Up Shirt vs Pendleton Women's Board Shirt
  • Everyday Plaid Button-Up Oversized Flannel vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best women's cotton plaid button-up shirts
  • Best women's plaid button-up shirts
Long Sleeve
Gender—Female