StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Both are 100% cotton plaid button-ups for women, so the choice comes down to fit and fabric weight. The Barbour Mooreland is cut loose with a pleated back and a beige check, and it needs a cold wash and line dry. The Lucky Brand is a softer washed cotton with a chest pocket, a thicker hand-feel owners like, and it can go in the tumble dryer. Buy the Barbour for a roomier, more polished look; buy the Lucky Brand for an easy everyday shirt that takes less care.

  • Choose the Barbour Mooreland if you want a loose, roomy plaid shirt with a pleated back and a muted beige check that dresses up a little.
  • Choose the Lucky Brand if you want a soft washed cotton shirt with a chest pocket, a bolder multicolor plaid and machine-dry care.

Prices

  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt: $100.00 at Nordstrom (checked today)
  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt: $79.50 at Nordstrom (checked today)
  • Difference: the Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt is $20.50 cheaper than the Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt today
Barbour
Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt

Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt

Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt

$100.00at NordstromChecked 2 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Loose fit with pleated back gives room through the shoulders
  • Muted beige check works for office and casual wear
  • 100% cotton oxford-style cloth holds its shape
  • Barbour heritage branding and construction
Cons
  • No chest pocket
  • Loose cut can look boxy on smaller frames
  • Cold wash only, no tumble drying
  • Beige check shows stains more than dark plaids
Lucky Brand
Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

5(1 rating)
$79.50at NordstromChecked 46 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Soft washed cotton feels broken in from the start
  • Tumble dry care is simple
  • Chest pocket adds function
  • Owners praise the colors and the thicker fabric
Cons
  • Standard fit may feel snug through the shoulders
  • Bold multicolor plaid is harder to dress up
  • Only one pocket
  • Less structured than an oxford-style shirt

What separates them

Barbour Mooreland Plaid ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
FitLoose cut with back pleats for extra roomStandard button-up cut, no pleats
Fabric feelCrisp 100% cotton oxford-style weaveSoft washed cotton, described as fairly thick
CareMachine wash at 30 degrees, no dryer listedMachine wash and tumble dry
PocketsNo chest pocketOne chest pocket
Pattern and colorBeige check, muted and understatedMulticolor nightshadow plaid, bolder
Collar and cuffsShirt collar, long sleevesSpread collar, long sleeves with button cuffs
Brand characterBritish heritage outerwear label, more traditional stylingAmerican denim-and-casual label, relaxed styling

Price history

$100.00$53.26
Nov 10Nov 18
  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt: lowest $100.00 on Nov 10 at Nordstrom; $100.00 on Nov 18.
  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt: lowest $53.26 on Nov 17 at Nordstrom; $79.50 on Nov 18.

Prices at every store

Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt

  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $100.00Free shippingChecked 2 h ago
    Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Prices and history →

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

  • NordstromNew

    In stock

    $79.50Free shippingChecked 46 min ago
    Visit Nordstrom

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecBarbour Mooreland Plaid ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
Washing Instructions30 DegreesTumble Dry
PatternCheckeredCheckered
ClosureButtonsButtons
NecklineShirt CollarShirt Collar
SleevesLong SleeveLong Sleeve
ColorBeigeMulticolor
MaterialCottonCotton
GenderFemaleFemale
Cotton (%)100100
Number of Pieces (pcs)1—
FitLoose—
Age GroupAdult—
Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
SpecBarbour Mooreland Plaid ShirtLucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt
Sportswear GarmentNo—

What reviewers say

Barbour Mooreland Plaid Shirt

Owners describe it as a well-made everyday plaid shirt with a roomy, comfortable fit. Most praise the soft cotton and the classic check; a few find the cut too loose and the fabric thinner than expected.

What people mention
  • FitMixedOwners like the relaxed roominess, but some find it boxy through the waist and short in the body.
  • FabricMixedThe cotton is called soft and breathable, though a few say it is thinner than they expected for the brand.
  • PatternPraisedThe large plaid check is the main draw, described as classic and easy to style.
  • BuildPraisedStitching and buttons are reported as solid, with pleats adding comfort across the back.

Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt

Buyers describe it as a great shirt overall, praising the colors and the fabric, which several note is pretty thick in a good way.

What people mention
  • Fabric weightPraisedBuyers say the cotton is pretty thick and like the substantial feel.
  • ColorsPraisedReviewers call the plaid colors great.
  • Overall qualityPraisedBuyers sum it up as a great shirt overall.

Questions and answers

Which is better for work?
The Barbour Mooreland. Its muted beige check and oxford-style cotton read more polished, and the loose cut layers over a tee without pulling.
Which feels softer out of the box?
The Lucky Brand. Its cotton is washed before sale, so it feels soft immediately. The Barbour starts crisper and softens over several washes.
Which is easier to care for?
The Lucky Brand. It can go in the tumble dryer. The Barbour is labeled for a 30-degree wash with no dryer, so plan to hang it dry.
Is the Barbour worth stepping up to?
If you want a roomier fit, a pleated back and a quieter check, yes. If you want soft fabric, a pocket and simple care, the Lucky Brand covers that.
Which runs roomier?
The Barbour. It is cut loose with back pleats. The Lucky Brand is a standard button-up, so check its size chart if you are between sizes.
Do either have pockets?
Only the Lucky Brand has a chest pocket. The Barbour Mooreland has no pocket.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • True Religion Long-Sleeve Plaid Button-Up Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid
  • Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid vs Lucky Brand Cropped Plaid Corduroy Button-Up Shirt
  • Pendleton Women's Board Shirt vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid
  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt vs Free People Ashley Plaid Shirt
  • Everyday Plaid Button-Up Oversized Flannel vs Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt
  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt vs GAP Fall Outfits Women Fashion Cotton Plaid Flannel Button Up Long Sleeve Shirts Collared 2024 Casual Work Tops - Nixie Plaid Medium
  • Barbour Mooreland Plaid Cotton Button-Up Shirt vs Style & Co Women's Plaid Cotton Gauze Button-Up Shirt
  • Everyday Plaid Button-Up Oversized Flannel vs Lucky Brand Plaid Button-Up Shirt - Nightshadow Multi Plaid

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best women's cotton plaid button-up shirts
  • Best women's plaid button-up shirts