Which is better for an uncovered porch?

The Polywood. It is built to withstand storms and strong winds and carries a 20-year warranty. The Costway set is listed for bedroom use and has no weather rating.

Is the Polywood worth $49 more than two Costway chairs?

If you need two seats, the Costway set is cheaper per chair. If you want one chair that lasts decades outdoors, the Polywood's warranty and recycled lumber justify $199.00.

Which holds more weight?

The Polywood is rated to 300 lbs. Costway does not publish a weight capacity for its set.

Which is more comfortable?

The Costway comes with a cushioned seat, so it feels softer immediately. The Polywood uses a contoured slat seat that drains water and holds up outdoors; add a cushion if you want padding.

Do both need assembly?

Yes. Polywood includes hardware and a guide. Costway requires adult assembly and includes tools.

The Polywood, by a wide margin. Recycled plastic lumber does not rust or rot, and the 20-year warranty covers it. The Costway's metal frame has no stated warranty.

Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair vs Costway 2 PCS Rocking Chair with Cushioned Seat, Slatted Back & Curved Armrests, Black + Gray

Buy the Polywood Presidential if you want one chair that survives years outdoors with no upkeep; its 20-year warranty and recycled lumber back that up. Buy the Costway set if you need two seats for a small budget and will keep them on a covered porch or indoors. On November 3, 2026 the Polywood is $199.00 at The Home Depot, while the Costway pair is $149.99 at Target — about $75 per chair.

Today the Costway 2 PCS Rocking Chair with Cushioned Seat, Slatted Back & Curved Armrests, Black + Gray costs $49.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent