Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair vs Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair
Buy the Polywood Presidential if the chair will live outdoors or get heavy use. Its recycled HDPE lumber shrugs off rain, sun and wind, it holds 300 lbs, and it carries a 20-year warranty. Buy the Three Posts chair if you want a real wood look indoors or on a covered porch and want to spend less. As of November 3, 2026, the Polywood is $199.00 at The Home Depot and the Three Posts is $125.99 at Wayfair, a gap of about $73.
Today the Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair costs $73.01 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair
4.7Choose the Polywood Presidential if the chair stays outside year-round, needs to hold up to weather and heavy sitters, or you want a 20-year warranty.
- Recycled plastic lumber will not rot, splinter or need painting
- 300 lb capacity suits most sitters
- 20-year warranty and made in Indiana
- Contoured seat with rolled arms and a classic slat back
- Five color choices, including Aruba, Lemon and Lime
What separates them
| Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair | Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair | |
|---|---|---|
| Frame material | Recycled POLYWOOD (HDPE) lumber | Solid wood |
| Weather resistance | Withstands storms and strong winds; low maintenance, easy to clean | Solid wood needs cover or regular sealing outdoors |
| Weight capacity | 300 lbs | Not stated |
| Warranty | 20 years | Not stated |
| Price, as of November 3, 2026 | $199.00 at The Home Depot | $125.99 at Wayfair |
| Seat | Contoured slat seat, 20 in wide, 18.6 in deep, 16.1 in high | Not stated |
| Dimensions | 26.1 in wide, 33.8 in deep, 44.2 in tall | 23.5 in wide, 45 in tall |
Price history
- Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair: lowest $199.00 on Nov 3 at The Home Depot.
- Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair: lowest $125.99 on Nov 3 at Wayfair.
Prices at every store
Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair
- WayfairNew
In stock
$299.00Free shippingObserved at 7:26 AM - The Home DepotNew
Availability unknown
$199.00Free shippingObserved at 7:26 AM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$229.00Free shippingObserved at 7:26 AM - Lowe'sNew
Availability unknown
$269.00Free shippingObserved at 7:26 AM
Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair
- WayfairNew
In stock
$125.99Observed at 9:03 AM
Specs compared
| Spec | Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair | Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 44.2 in | 45 in tall |
| Width | 26.1 in | 23.5 in wide |
| Chair Type | Rocking | — |
| Color | Black, Aruba, Green, Lemon, Lime | — |
| Included Items | Hardware, Assembly Guide, Outdoor Chair | — |
| Material | POLYWOOD | — |
| Movement Type | Rocking | — |
| Seat Comfort | Contoured seat | — |
| Weight Capacity | 300 lbs. | — |
| Depth | 33.8 in | — |
What reviewers say
Polywood Presidential Rocking Chair
With 4.7 out of 5 from 1,293 ratings, owners largely report a sturdy, comfortable rocker that holds up outdoors. Complaints center on assembly effort and the plastic look up close.
- Sturdy and stable rocking motion
- Holds up through rain and sun without fading or rot
- Comfortable contoured seat for long sits
- Easy to wipe clean
- Assembly takes time and two people help
- Looks like plastic rather than wood up close
- Heavier than expected to reposition
Three Posts Black Solid Wood Rocking Chair
With 4.5 out of 5 from 56 ratings, owners are largely satisfied. Most praise the sturdy wood build and the look for the price; the common complaint is that the seat is firm without a cushion.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for an uncovered porch?
- The Polywood Presidential. Its recycled HDPE lumber is built to withstand storms and strong winds and needs no sealing. Solid wood like the Three Posts will weather unless it is covered or refinished.
- Is the Polywood worth about $73 more?
- For outdoor use, yes. You get a 300 lb capacity, a 20-year warranty and no maintenance. Indoors or under a roof, the Three Posts does the same job for less.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Polywood, on paper. It has a 20-year warranty and plastic lumber does not rot. The Three Posts lists no warranty, and wood life depends on how well it is kept dry.
- Which is better for a heavy sitter?
- The Polywood. It is rated to 300 lbs. Three Posts does not state a weight capacity, so check with the store before relying on it.
- Which fits a small porch?
- The Three Posts is narrower at 23.5 in versus 26.1 in. The Polywood is deeper at 33.8 in, so leave room behind it for the rocking motion.
- Do the colors differ?
- Yes. Polywood comes in Black, Aruba, Green, Lemon and Lime. The Three Posts chair is listed in Black only.