Which is better for a picky cat?

Pate is the safer bet for many finicky cats because it is smooth and uniform. If your cat already licks gravy and leaves the meat, Gravy Lovers fits better.

Is the Pate pack grain-free?

Yes. The Pate collection is listed as grain-free. Gravy Lovers is not described as grain-free.

Which is better for a kitten?

Gravy Lovers is labeled for all life stages, so it fits a kitten. The Pate title says adult, though the store page says it suits kittens and adult cats, so check the can label.

Which is better for weight management?

The Pate collection lists weight management as its health concern. Gravy Lovers is positioned for energy and vitality instead.

Is Gravy Lovers worth $28.06?

That is about $1.17 per 3 oz can at PetSmart as of November 3, 2026, which is typical for a Fancy Feast variety pack. Whether it is worth it depends on whether your cat eats gravy food; the Pate pack's price was not provided for comparison.

Do both packs have the same amount of food?

Yes. Both are 24 cans of 3 oz, 72 oz total or 4.5 lb.

Purina Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Food, Wet Cat Food Collection, 3 oz Cans, 24 Pack vs Purina Fancy Feast Poultry & Beef Classic Pate Collection Wet Cat Food, Tender Beef-Chicken-Turkey & Giblets, Adult (24 x 3 oz)

Buy the Classic Pate if you want a grain-free, high-protein pate for an adult cat or a picky eater. Buy Gravy Lovers if your cat prefers shredded meat in gravy and you want a food labeled for all life stages. Both are 24-can, 3 oz variety packs of 4.5 lb. As of November 3, 2026, Gravy Lovers is $28.06 at PetSmart, and the Pate pack's price was not provided.

Ask our shopping agent