Which is better for a picky cat?

Pate textures like Fancy Feast are widely accepted by finicky eaters, and its 4.7 rating from 5,697 ratings backs that. If your cat only eats shreds or flakes, go with Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Flaked.

Which pack lasts longer?

Fancy Feast, clearly: 24 cans versus 12. At one can a day that is about 24 days versus 12.

Is the Fancy Feast pack worth the extra cost?

Compare the per-ounce price on both listings. Fancy Feast gives you twice the cans, so it usually wins per ounce unless the Blue Buffalo box is discounted heavily.

Yes. Blue Buffalo leaves out corn, wheat and soy, and Fancy Feast lists grain-free formulas.

Can kittens eat either one?

Fancy Feast states it suits kittens and adult cats. Blue Buffalo does not state a life stage on the pack, so ask your vet before feeding it to a kitten.

Which has more protein variety?

Blue Buffalo rotates tuna, chicken and shrimp; Fancy Feast rotates beef, chicken and turkey & giblets. Pick by what your cat actually eats.

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Flaked Variety vs Purina Fancy Feast Poultry & Beef Classic Pate Collection Wet Cat Food, Tender Beef-Chicken-Turkey & Giblets, Adult (24 x 3 oz)

Buy the Fancy Feast Poultry & Beef Pate Collection for most cats: you get 24 cans instead of 12, a smooth pate picky eaters tend to accept, and a higher rating (4.7 from 5,697 ratings vs 4.4 from 4,764). Buy Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Flaked if your cat prefers shredded fish-forward textures or you want tuna and shrimp in the rotation. Both are 3 oz cans; the Fancy Feast pack is twice the food for roughly the same shelf space, so check the live price gap on both before you commit.

Ask our shopping agent