Which is better for a picky cat?

The Blue Buffalo pack has far more buyer feedback at 4.4 out of 5 from 4,764 ratings, which suggests broader acceptance. The Fancy Feast pack averages 3.5 from just 6 ratings, so its record is thin. Buy one pack of each and see which texture your cat finishes.

Is the Fancy Feast pack cheaper per can?

At $12.99 for 12 cans at Petsense as of November 3, 2026, it works out to about $1.08 a can. No price is given for the Blue Buffalo pack, so check its live price across stores before calling either one the better deal.

Which has more protein?

The Fancy Feast pack lists 11.0% crude protein on an as-fed basis with 80% moisture. Blue Buffalo does not publish a guaranteed analysis in this listing, so a direct protein comparison is not possible from what is shown.

Are either of these grain-free?

Blue Buffalo states no corn, wheat or soy and no by-product meals. Fancy Feast states no artificial preservatives but does not claim grain-free. Check the full ingredient panel on each can if grains matter to you.

How many cans a day should I feed?

Fancy Feast gives a guide of one 3 oz can per 1.2 kg of body weight daily, so a 4.5 kg cat needs roughly four cans. Blue Buffalo gives no feeding guide here; follow the label on the can and your vet's advice.

Which is better for a multi-cat household?

Both are 12-can variety packs, so both let you rotate flavors. Fancy Feast explicitly markets the pack for multi-cat homes and lists 73 kcal per can, which makes splitting cans across cats easier to track.

Purina Fancy Feast Medleys Florentine Collection Gourmet Wet Cat Food Variety Pack - (12) 3 oz. Cans vs Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Flaked Variety

Buy the Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Flaked Variety if you want a flaked, gravy-free texture with meat as the first ingredient and a strong track record of buyer ratings. Buy the Fancy Feast Medleys Florentine Collection if you want shredded-style recipes with garden greens in a light broth and a lower upfront price. The Fancy Feast pack is $12.99 at Petsense as of November 3, 2026; the Blue Buffalo pack has no price given here, so compare its live price across stores before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent