R4 Sectional Sofa vs Calliope 4-Piece Modular Sectional

Buy the R4 if you want a proven, low-risk modular sofa: 398 ratings at 4.5, a 100-day trial and a lifetime warranty are hard to beat. The Calliope is the pick for looks and texture, with hand-tufted curves, movable arm cushions and vegan shearling or velvet covers, but it has far fewer ratings and no stated trial or warranty. On build, the R4 leans on SmartFoam and YKK zippers; the Calliope leans on tufting and deep cushions, which feel plusher but are harder to clean.

• Choose the R4 Sectional Sofa if you want a modular sofa with a long trial, a lifetime warranty and a large track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the Calliope 4-Piece Performance Modular Sectional if you want a sculpted, hand-tufted look with movable arm cushions and fabric choices like vegan shearling.