Which is better for a kids' birthday party?

The Nostalgia. It is electric, so you can crank out cones without hand fatigue, and the safety switch and suction-cup feet matter with kids around. The Reemix is cheaper but manual, which slows you down at a party.

Is the Nostalgia worth the extra $7?

For most buyers, yes. You get an electric motor, a safety switch, a cup and 7 stores to compare, versus one store for the Reemix. The Reemix only wins if price and stainless steel are your priorities.

Neither maker publishes a lifespan. The Reemix's stainless steel body resists rust better, but the Nostalgia has no hand-crank mechanism to wear out and a much larger review base. Treat both as light-duty home machines.

Do both use regular ice cubes?

The Nostalgia is specified for regular-sized ice cubes. The Reemix listing does not state an ice type, so check the box before buying if you plan to use large freezer cubes.

Which is easier to store?

The Reemix is a manual unit with no cord, so it packs away easily. The Nostalgia is a 10 by 9 by 14 inch countertop unit weighing 4 lbs, so it takes up shelf space.

Can I use either without an outlet?

Only the Reemix. It is manual, so it works anywhere. The Nostalgia needs a 120 V outlet.

Reemix Electric Shaved Ice Machine Snow Cone Maker vs Nostalgia Classic Retro Snow Cone Maker

Buy the Reemix if you want the lowest price and a stainless steel body; it is $32.89 at Walmart as of November 4, 2026. Buy the Nostalgia if you want a proven, widely sold electric maker with a safety switch and suction-cup feet; it is $39.99 at Wayfair as of November 4, 2026. The gap is about $7, and the Nostalgia's larger review base and 7 stores make it the safer pick for most households.

Today the Reemix Electric Shaved Ice Machine Snow Cone Maker costs $7.10 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.