Which is better for cutting?

Loaded Protein. It has fewer calories, carbs and sugar per serving at the same 25g of protein.

Which tastes more like a dessert?

Cosmic Brownies. It is a Little Debbie collab with candy inclusions, and most buyers praise the flavor.

Do the inclusions in Cosmic Brownies bother people?

Some do. A share of buyers call the confetti pieces artificial and sugary and say they detract from the brownie taste.

Are they the same protein source?

Largely yes. Both use whey with isolate as the primary source and deliver 25g per serving.

Is Loaded Protein worth stepping up to over Cosmic Brownies?

If you want leaner macros and a neutral shake, yes. If flavor is the point, Cosmic Brownies is the draw.

Buyers report Cosmic Brownies mixes well; Loaded Protein is a standard whey isolate that mixes in water per the label.

Ryse Cosmic Brownies Protein vs RYSE Loaded Protein

Both are 25g whey protein powders with added prebiotic fiber and MCTs, so the choice comes down to flavor and macros. Cosmic Brownies is a Little Debbie flavor collab with candy inclusions; Loaded Protein is the plain, lower-calorie everyday option. Owners praise Cosmic Brownies' flavor but some dislike the confetti inclusions and their artificial sugary taste. Loaded Protein is the safer pick if you want a leaner, no-nonsense shake.

Choose the Ryse Cosmic Brownies if you want a dessert-style shake and the candy inclusions don't bother you.
Choose the Ryse Loaded Protein if you want fewer calories and sugar and a straight chocolate-style protein without inclusions.

Prices

Ryse Cosmic Brownies Protein: $49.99 at Vitacost.com (last seen Nov 13)
RYSE Loaded Protein: $49.99 at Academy Sports (last seen Nov 13)
Difference: both cost the same at the latest prices (Nov 13)