Which is better for all-day walking?

The Mattison. Its platform and cushioning draw no blister complaints, while Darla shoppers report blisters and skin peeling after short walks.

Does the Sam Edelman Darla run true to size?

No. Shoppers say it runs big and sizing is inconsistent, so try a half size down.

Is the Dr. Martens Mattison worth the extra money?

If you want genuine leather and suede and a higher-rated fit, yes. The Darla is the cheaper pick at $51.93 at Macy's as of November 7, 2026.

The Mattison. Its leather and suede upper and platform sole are built for more wear than the Darla's faux-leather mix.

Can I wear the Mattison in fall?

Yes. Dr. Martens lists it for spring, summer and fall; the Darla is listed for summer only.

Which has better arch support?

Shoppers credit the Darla with decent arch support for a flat slide. The Mattison relies on its cushioned platform instead.

Sam Edelman Darla Multi Buckle Slide Sandal vs Dr. Martens Mattison Slide Sandals

Buy the Dr. Martens Mattison if you want a leather slide that holds up and fits true to size. Buy the Sam Edelman Darla if you want a lower-priced, flat everyday slide and can size down. The Darla is $51.93 at Macy's as of November 7, 2026; no current price was given for the Mattison, so compare it at checkout.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.