Which is better for all-day walking?

The Darla is flat with a rubber outsole and cushioning, which suits long walks better than a platform. The Maxxy's platform and leather outsole are heavier and stiffer.

The Maxxy's leather and suede upper should hold up longer than the Darla's faux leather mix. The Darla's rubber outsole resists wear and water better than the Maxxy's leather outsole.

Is the Darla worth it over the Maxxy?

At $51.93 at Macy's as of November 7, 2026, the Darla is the cheaper, lighter option. The Maxxy price was not provided, so check it before deciding whether the leather and platform are worth the difference.

Which fits wider feet?

Both are listed in medium width. Darla buyers report it runs big, so consider sizing down. The Maxxy has no fit complaints in its small rating set.

Which is better for summer?

Both work for summer. The Darla is listed for summer only, while the Maxxy is listed for all seasons, so it carries into cooler months.

Do the Darla straps cause blisters?

Some buyers report blisters and skin peeling from the straps and stitching after short walks. Break them in gradually and consider a bandage on hot spots.

Sam Edelman Darla Multi Buckle Slide Sandal vs Dr. Martens Maxxy Slide Sandals

Buy the Sam Edelman Darla if you want a flat, braided-strap slide at a lower price. Buy the Dr. Martens Maxxy if you want a leather platform slide with a chunkier sole. The Darla is $51.93 at Macy's as of November 7, 2026. The Maxxy price was not provided, so compare it at checkout before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.